01 · Learn the idea
A mixture can retain visible parts
With teacher-approved materials, stir a small amount of sand into water in a clear cup. Observe, then let it rest. The grains remain solid and can settle. Pour the mixture through a suitable filter over another cup; much of the sand stays on the filter while water passes through. The mixture did not turn every grain into water.
Some properties can still be used to separate substances. Sand’s grain size helps a filter trap it. In a sand-and-iron mixture, attraction to a magnet can separate iron; mixing does not automatically erase magnetism.
02 · Build understanding
A solution still contains its solute
Place water and a small inner cup of salt together inside a sealable transparent container. Seal it and measure the total mass. Tip it so the salt mixes with the water without opening the container, then gently swirl. Reweigh the same sealed container with all its parts. Follow teacher directions and do not taste materials.
Before mixing, salt has visible crystals and water is liquid. After enough stirring with a small enough amount of salt, the crystals are no longer visible and a clear solution forms. The salt has not vanished: it is distributed throughout the water. If nothing enters or leaves, total mass stays the same within measurement limits. A 180-g system remains about 180 g, including the container. Ordinary filtering does not remove dissolved salt as it removes sand.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Conduct or observe both mixtures. Draw before-and-after views and record properties. Explain why sand can remain visible while dissolved salt is not visible. Use before-and-after mass measurements of the same sealed system to decide whether matter was lost.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A correct explanation distinguishes visible solid sand from dissolved salt distributed through water. Conserved mass supports that salt remains in the closed system. If measured masses differ, investigate a leak, a removed part, or balance precision before claiming that dissolving destroys matter.
- Describe retained sand properties and changed appearance of salt.
- Compare the same complete sealed system.
- Use measurements to support conservation rather than visibility alone.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Track substances through mixing: practice →