Learn · Grade 4 Social Studies

Finding and judging sources

Differentiate between, locate and use valid primary and secondary sources to acquire information about Texas.

Lesson 1 of 12About 12 minutesTEKS 4.19(A)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Kinds of source

Sources about Texas include documents, letters, diaries, photographs, maps, artefacts, interviews, biographies, books, articles and websites.

A primary source comes from the time of the event or from someone who was there. A secondary source describes or explains the event afterwards.

02 · Build understanding

What makes a source valid

A valid source is one you have reason to trust for the question you are asking. Ask who made it, when, and whether it says where its information came from.

A source with no author, no date and no stated evidence should not be relied on, however confident it sounds.

who made it · when · where did their information come from

03 · Build understanding

Locating sources

Libraries, museums, county records, state archives and reputable websites all hold material about Texas. A local library often has material about your own county that is available nowhere else.

People are sources too. An interview with someone who remembers an event is a primary source you can create yourself.

04 · Build understanding

Match the source to the question

Validity depends on the question. A newspaper from 1901 is an excellent source for how people reacted to Spindletop and a poor one for what geologists now understand about the field.

So do not ask only whether a source is good. Ask what it is good for.

Apply and explain

Your turn

List four kinds of source about Texas and say whether each is usually primary or secondary. Give three questions that test whether a source is valid. Then explain why a newspaper from 1901 is a good source for one question and a poor source for another.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Four kinds of source: a diary written at the time, which is primary; a photograph taken of an event, which is primary; a biography written afterwards, which is secondary; and an encyclopedia article, which is secondary. Three questions that test validity are who made the source, when it was made, and whether it says where its information came from. A source with no author, no date and no stated evidence should not be relied on however confident it sounds. A newspaper from 1901 is an excellent source for how people reacted to the Spindletop gusher, because it records what was being said at the time by people who were there. It is a poor source for what geologists now understand about that oil field, because the understanding of the geology has advanced enormously since then. Validity therefore depends on the question, so the right test is not whether a source is good but what it is good for.

  • Four sources correctly classified.
  • Three validity questions given.
  • The same source shown to be strong for one question and weak for another.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Social studies skills practice →