01 · Learn the idea
Why accounts differ
A soldier's letter about a battle and a history book about the same battle will not say the same things, and neither is necessarily wrong.
The letter records one person's position, knowledge and feelings at that moment. The book gathers many accounts and adds what later became known.
02 · Build understanding
What each does best
A primary source gives immediacy and detail no summary can match: what it looked like, what was said, what was feared.
A secondary source gives scope and context: what caused it, what followed, and how it fits with everything else known.
primary: close up · secondary: wide view
03 · Build understanding
How to compare them
Put the two side by side and ask three questions. What do they agree on? Where do they differ? What does each include that the other leaves out?
Agreement between independent sources strengthens a fact. A detail that appears in only one deserves a note saying so.
04 · Build understanding
When they conflict
If the accounts conflict, ask who was in a position to know, when each was written, and whether either had a reason to shape the story.
If you cannot settle it, report the conflict. Saying that the sources disagree, and how, is more useful than choosing one and hiding the other.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Explain why a soldier's letter and a history book about the same battle differ without either being wrong. Say what each kind of source does best. Give the three questions you ask when comparing them. Then explain what to do when two accounts conflict.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A soldier's letter records one person's position, knowledge and feelings at a single moment, while a history book gathers many accounts and adds what became known later. They differ because they are built from different material, not because one is necessarily wrong. A primary source does immediacy and detail best, giving what things looked like, what was said and what was feared. A secondary source does scope and context best, giving causes, consequences and how the event fits with everything else known. When comparing them, ask what they agree on, where they differ, and what each includes that the other leaves out. Agreement between independent sources strengthens a fact, and a detail appearing in only one deserves a note saying so. When two accounts conflict, ask who was in a position to know, when each was written, and whether either had a reason to shape the story. If the conflict cannot be settled, report it, because saying that the sources disagree and how is more useful than choosing one and hiding the other.
- The difference explained by position and hindsight.
- Strengths of each kind of source.
- Three comparison questions and a conflict procedure.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Social studies skills practice →