01 · Learn the idea
A procedure you can run
Democratic procedures are steps a group agrees to follow so that a decision is made fairly. A workable set: state the question, propose options, discuss them, vote, and record the result.
Agree the rules before you begin. Who may propose, how long each person speaks, and what counts as winning all have to be settled while nobody knows the outcome.
state the question → propose → discuss → vote → record
02 · Build understanding
State the question well
The question must be one the group can actually decide. "Should our class choose a recycling project or a park clean-up for service day?" is decidable; "should there be less litter?" is not, because everyone already agrees.
A badly stated question wastes the whole procedure, so it is worth getting right before anything else.
03 · Build understanding
Discussion before the vote
Discussion is where the decision is actually improved. People raise problems with options, suggest changes and sometimes combine two proposals.
Voting without discussion measures opinions that nobody has tested. The vote should come after the arguments have been heard.
04 · Build understanding
Record and respect the result
Write down what was decided, the vote count and who is responsible for the next step. A decision nobody recorded is usually disputed within a week.
Those who voted the other way remain part of the group and should be invited into carrying the decision out. That is what makes the next vote work as well.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Give the five steps of a democratic procedure for deciding a school issue. Explain what makes a question decidable, with an example of a poor one. Explain why discussion should come before the vote. Then explain what should be recorded and how the losing side should be treated.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
The five steps are: state the question, propose options, discuss them, vote, and record the result. The rules should be agreed before starting, including who may propose, how long each person speaks and what counts as winning, because those have to be settled while nobody knows the outcome. A question is decidable when the group can actually choose between real options, such as whether the class should choose a recycling project or a park clean-up for service day. A poor question is one like "should there be less litter?", because everyone already agrees and there is nothing to decide. Discussion should come before the vote because discussion is where the decision is improved: people raise problems with options, suggest changes and sometimes combine two proposals, and voting first would only measure untested opinions. What should be recorded is what was decided, the vote count and who is responsible for the next step, since a decision nobody wrote down is usually disputed within a week. Those who voted the other way remain part of the group and should be invited into carrying the decision out, which is what keeps the next vote working.
- All five steps with rules fixed in advance.
- A decidable question contrasted with an undecidable one.
- Discussion-first argued, and recording plus inclusion of the minority.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Social studies skills practice →