Learn · Grade 4 Social Studies

Discussing topics with multiple perspectives

Apply foundational language skills to engage in civil discourse about social studies topics, including those with multiple perspectives.

Lesson 10 of 12About 12 minutesTEKS 4.21(E)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

What civil discourse is

Civil discourse means discussing a disagreement in a way that lets everyone be heard and lets the discussion reach somewhere.

It does not mean avoiding disagreement. A discussion where nobody disagrees has not tested anything.

02 · Build understanding

Rules that make it work

Let people finish. Respond to what was actually said rather than to what you assume they meant. Give reasons for your own view. Name your sources when you use a fact.

Ask a question when you do not understand, rather than guessing at someone's position and arguing with the guess.

03 · Build understanding

Disagree with the argument

Say that a claim is wrong and why. Do not say that the person is foolish for holding it.

The difference is practical, not merely polite. An attack on a person invites a defence of the person, and the argument is never examined.

"that claim is wrong because…" not "you are wrong to think…"

04 · Build understanding

When a topic is painful

Some Texas history involves slavery, dispossession and violence, and these affect people in the room differently. That is a fact about the discussion, not a reason to avoid the subject.

If someone is upset, stop and listen rather than pressing your point. Acknowledging what a topic costs someone is part of discussing it honestly, and the discussion can continue afterwards.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Define civil discourse and explain why it does not mean avoiding disagreement. Give four rules that make a discussion work. Explain the practical difference between disagreeing with an argument and attacking a person. Then explain what to do when a topic is painful for someone in the discussion.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Civil discourse means discussing a disagreement in a way that lets everyone be heard and lets the discussion reach somewhere. It does not mean avoiding disagreement, because a discussion in which nobody disagrees has not tested anything. Four rules that make it work: let people finish; respond to what was actually said rather than what you assume they meant; give reasons for your own view; and ask a question when you do not understand instead of guessing at someone's position and arguing with the guess. The difference between disagreeing with an argument and attacking a person is practical rather than merely polite. Saying a claim is wrong and giving the reason keeps attention on the claim, while saying the person is foolish invites a defence of the person, after which the argument itself is never examined. When a topic is painful, which some Texas history involving slavery, dispossession and violence certainly is, stop and listen rather than pressing your point. Acknowledging what a topic costs someone is part of discussing it honestly, and the discussion can continue afterwards.

  • Civil discourse defined without equating it to agreement.
  • Four workable rules.
  • The practical argument against personal attacks, and a response to distress.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Social studies skills practice →