01 · Learn the idea
Develop the claim from the evidence
Gather and examine the evidence first, then state what it supports. A claim decided in advance turns research into a search for agreement.
It is perfectly respectable to change your claim as you read. That is what reading the evidence is for.
02 · Build understanding
Main idea first, then support
State the claim clearly at the start so your audience knows what you are arguing. Then give each supporting idea with the evidence behind it.
Say how each piece of evidence supports the claim. Evidence placed beside a claim without explanation leaves the audience to build the argument themselves.
claim → supporting idea + evidence → supporting idea + evidence → conclusion
03 · Build understanding
Choosing the mode
Written work suits detail that a reader may want to check or return to. Oral delivery suits reaching a group and allows questions. Visual work suits comparisons, sequences and places.
Many presentations use more than one. A spoken report with a map and a graph delivers what none of the three would deliver alone.
04 · Build understanding
Name your sources
Say where your evidence came from, whichever mode you use. In writing that is a bibliography; in a talk it is naming the main sources aloud or on a final slide.
Naming sources lets an audience check the work, and being checkable is what separates an argument from an assertion.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Explain why a claim should be developed from evidence rather than decided first. Describe how to structure a presentation of a claim. Say which mode suits detail, which suits a group and which suits comparison. Then explain why sources must be named whatever the mode.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A claim should be developed from evidence rather than decided first, because a claim settled in advance turns research into a search for agreement, and anything that does not fit is quietly left out. Changing your claim as you read is a sign the research is working. To structure a presentation, state the claim clearly at the start so the audience knows what is being argued, then give each supporting idea with the evidence behind it, and say how each piece of evidence supports the claim rather than leaving the audience to build the argument. Written work suits detail a reader may want to check or return to. Oral delivery suits reaching a group at once and allows questions. Visual work suits comparisons, sequences and places, so a map or a graph carries what a paragraph would carry slowly. Sources must be named whatever the mode, as a bibliography in writing or as main sources named aloud or on a final slide in a talk, because naming them lets an audience check the work, and being checkable is what separates an argument from an assertion.
- Evidence-first argued, with the failure mode of deciding early.
- A structure that leads with the claim and links evidence to it.
- Modes matched to purposes, and the checkability argument for sources.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Social studies skills practice →