01 · Learn the idea
What a central claim is
The central claim is the main thing a source wants you to accept. It is a statement, not a subject.
"The cattle industry" is a topic. "The cattle drives ended because of the railroad and barbed wire, not because demand fell" is a claim, because someone could disagree with it.
02 · Build understanding
Finding it
Look at the opening and the closing, where writers usually state their point, and at any sentence the rest of the source works to support.
A useful test: if you removed the sentence, would the source lose its purpose? If so, it is the central claim.
could a reasonable person disagree? → then it is a claim
03 · Build understanding
Claim and support
The claim is what is argued; the evidence is what supports it. Confusing the two is a common error, because evidence is often the more memorable sentence.
Ask what each fact is doing. A fact in an argument is there to hold up the claim, not to stand alone.
04 · Build understanding
Claims in primary sources
Primary sources have claims too. A letter arguing that a town should raise money for a school is making a claim as clearly as an article does.
Even a diary can carry one, when the writer is arguing with themselves about what happened or what should be done.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Explain the difference between a topic and a central claim, with an example about the cattle industry. Give two ways of locating the claim in a source. Explain the relationship between a claim and its evidence. Then explain whether primary sources have claims.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A topic is a subject, such as the cattle industry. A central claim is a statement the source wants you to accept, such as that the cattle drives ended because of the railroad and barbed wire rather than because demand fell. The test is whether a reasonable person could disagree, which they could with the claim but not with the topic. Two ways of locating the claim are to look at the opening and closing, where writers usually state their point, and to ask whether removing a particular sentence would cost the source its purpose. If it would, that sentence is the central claim. The relationship between claim and evidence is that the claim is what is argued and the evidence is what holds it up, so each fact in an argument is doing a job for the claim rather than standing alone. Confusing the two is common, because a striking fact is often more memorable than the claim it supports. Primary sources do have claims. A letter arguing that a town should raise money for a school is making one as clearly as an article does, and even a diary can carry one when the writer argues with themselves about what happened or what should be done.
- Topic and claim distinguished by arguability, with the example.
- Two location methods, including the removal test.
- Claim-evidence relationship, and primary sources included.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Social studies skills practice →