Learn · Grade 4 English Language Arts and Reading

Writing responses that compare sources

Write responses that demonstrate understanding of texts, including comparing and contrasting ideas across sources.

Lesson 2 of 6About 12 minutesTEKS 4.7(B)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Answer the question asked

A written response starts by answering the question directly. Retelling the text instead of answering is the most common way a response goes wrong.

Restating the question in your first sentence keeps you pointed at it: "The author thinks city parks matter because…"

02 · Build understanding

Comparing across sources

Comparing means saying where two sources agree; contrasting means saying where they differ. A full response usually needs both.

Both articles may agree that parks help a city, but one may say the reason is health while the other says the reason is cooler air. That difference is the interesting part.

03 · Build understanding

Organise point by point

Take one idea and say what each source says about it, then move to the next idea. That is easier to follow than describing one whole source and then the other.

Point-by-point organisation also forces you to compare, rather than leaving a reader to work out the relationship.

idea 1: source A says … source B says … · idea 2: …

04 · Build understanding

Name the source of each idea

Say which source each idea comes from. "The first article says" and "the second article argues" keep a reader oriented.

Without that, a reader cannot tell whose claim is whose, and a comparison that blurs the two sources is not a comparison at all.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Two articles both say city parks are valuable. The first says parks improve health because people exercise in them. The second says parks cool the city by providing shade. Write a response of a few sentences that compares and contrasts the two, organised point by point, and explain why answering the question matters more than retelling.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Both articles agree that city parks are valuable, but they give different reasons. On the question of who benefits, the first article focuses on the people who use the park, arguing that they are healthier because they exercise there. The second article focuses on the city as a whole, arguing that trees provide shade that lowers the temperature even for people who never enter the park. On the question of evidence, the first relies on what visitors do, while the second relies on what the trees themselves do. Taken together, they suggest parks are valuable both for the people in them and for the neighbourhood around them. Answering the question matters more than retelling because a retelling shows only that the text was read. The question asks what the sources claim and how they relate, and only a direct answer shows that the ideas were understood.

  • Both agreement and difference are stated.
  • Organisation is point by point with each idea attributed to a source.
  • The reason for answering rather than retelling is explained.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Responding to reading practice →