01 · Learn the idea
What counts as evidence
Text evidence is something the text actually says: a quoted phrase, a paraphrased detail, or a fact the author gives.
What you assume, or what you think usually happens, is not evidence. Evidence can be pointed at on the page.
02 · Build understanding
Evidence must fit the claim
The evidence has to support the point you are making. A true detail that has nothing to do with the claim weakens a response rather than strengthening it.
Before using a quotation, ask what it proves. If the answer is not your claim, find different evidence.
03 · Build understanding
Quote accurately
A quotation must use the author's exact words inside quotation marks. Changing words inside quotation marks misrepresents the text.
If exact wording is not needed, paraphrase instead and leave the quotation marks off. Both are honest; mixing them is not.
claim → evidence → explanation of how it supports the claim
04 · Build understanding
Explain the link
Evidence does not speak for itself. After giving it, say how it supports the claim.
The pattern is claim, evidence, explanation. Responses that stop after the evidence leave the reader to guess at the argument.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Explain what counts as text evidence and what does not. Then write a short response using the claim-evidence-explanation pattern for the claim that a character is nervous, inventing a suitable detail. Explain why a quotation must use exact words.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
Text evidence is something the text actually says: a quoted phrase, a paraphrased detail, or a fact the author supplies. What a reader assumes, or what usually happens in life, is not evidence, because it cannot be pointed at on the page. A response using the pattern: the claim is that Ravi is nervous before the audition. The evidence is that the text says he read the same line of his script four times without taking any of it in. The explanation is that re-reading without absorbing anything shows his attention is elsewhere, which is how nervousness shows itself even though the author never uses the word. A quotation must use exact words because quotation marks tell the reader these are the author's words, not yours. Changing anything inside them misrepresents the text, and if exact wording is not needed, a paraphrase without quotation marks is the honest alternative.
- Evidence and non-evidence are distinguished by whether it is on the page.
- A response following claim, evidence and explanation in order.
- The accuracy rule for quotations is justified.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Responding to reading practice →