01 · Learn the idea
Define the problem and criteria
Design a removable model planter cover that reduces water loss while leaving a central opening for a plant stem. Use paper, reusable foil, or teacher-approved fabric, no sharp tools, no chemical sealants, and a fictional materials budget of 10 tokens. Assign paper cost 2, foil 4, fabric 3 per cover. Criteria: reduce water loss compared with uncovered containers, remain removable, and preserve the same central opening. A no-plant model isolates evaporation; it cannot establish actual plant health.
Build two cover designs and an uncovered control, each with three identical containers, equal damp growing medium, and equal initial water additions. Randomize positions in one safe location. Record starting masses in grams with a balance, drawings of cover dimensions in millimeters, and visible properties. Weigh again at agreed equal intervals over at least two days. Keep spills, watering, and handling documented. Do not seal living plants inside containers.
02 · Build understanding
Organize and evaluate evidence
Use a raw data table for each container and time; plot mass against elapsed time as line graphs. Make a bar graph of mean mass loss by design, with replicate values visible. Make a scatter plot of starting water mass versus loss only if the class actually varied or measured those quantities; explain why a scatter plot is not appropriate for a categorical design label. A chart can combine cost, loss, removability, and qualitative observations. Use a spreadsheet to calculate loss = initial mass − final mass and check one calculation by hand.
Assess whether container differences, spills, airflow, balance precision, or unequal medium could explain outcomes. Select a design using both measured performance and constraints, revise one feature, and retest under comparable conditions. If no design meets the criteria, report that result and propose a next iteration rather than inventing success.
03 · Build understanding
Communicate and challenge a claim
First write an individual claim with data and a mechanism. In a group, create a labeled prototype drawing, a results poster, and a two-minute oral defense. A peer names one supporting measurement and one limitation, paraphrases the claim before disagreeing, and asks for evidence. The designers respond and revise their explanation when warranted.
The model can support a claim about evaporation in tested containers. It does not by itself establish better crop yield or healthier roots. A later live-plant study would need appropriate drainage, plant health measurements, matched conditions, and teacher oversight.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Build, test, revise, and retest the two cover designs. Submit raw measurements, graphs, a decision chart, prototype drawings, an individual explanation, and a group poster. Document one evidence-based disagreement and the resulting revision.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A defensible recommendation uses actual replicate mass losses, meets the budget and opening constraints, and states the no-plant model limitation. The explanation links cover properties with evaporation without claiming unmeasured plant benefits. Revised results must be distinguished from the initial test.
- Two designs and replicated control tested
- Tables, plots, chart, and drawings use actual data
- Constraints and uncertainty included in decision
- A revision is retested
- Individual and collaborative communication documented
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Design a water-conserving planter practice →