01 · Learn the idea
Test the explanation
A fictional advertisement claims, “Our additive doubles every plant’s growth.” It compares one treated plant by a sunny window with one untreated plant in a dark corner and shows only final heights. Identify the changed factors, missing initial measurements, lack of replication, and unsupported universal wording. The claim is not established merely because the treated plant is taller.
Propose a test with the same plant type, comparable starting size, matched light and water, randomized placement, several plants per condition, a defined growth measure, and an untreated control. Compare changes from baseline and variability, including unfavorable results. Decide what findings would support, weaken, or leave the claim unresolved. This is a design critique; do not purchase or apply unknown additives.
02 · Build understanding
Research biological work
Choose two careers connected with course activities, such as field ecologist, molecular laboratory scientist, or bioinformatics researcher. Begin with an institutional career profile or research-laboratory page, then consult a library career database or professional organization. Record the page title, organization, URL, access date, and what it actually supports; do not copy a job title into a list and call that research.
For each career, identify a real question practitioners investigate, typical tools or data, education or training described by the source, collaborative partners, and one uncertainty to ask a mentor. Requirements vary by role and employer. Compare which class activity resembles the work and which important parts the class model omits. Starting resource: https://www.genome.gov/careers-in-genomics .
Apply and explain
Your turn
Write an evidence-based critique of the advertisement and a proposed comparison. Then create two sourced career profiles and a comparison paragraph linking each role to a course investigation. Present one unanswered career question and a credible way to investigate it.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
The original comparison confounds additive and light and lacks baseline and replicate evidence. A stronger design controls those factors. Career profiles should summarize actual source findings, distinguish role-specific requirements from universal claims, and connect tools and questions with the course.
- Claim and design flaws distinguished
- Test could support or weaken the claim
- Two careers researched with traceable sources
- Tasks, tools, preparation, and uncertainty compared
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Critique a biology claim and explore careers practice →