01 · Learn the idea
Natural changes have different mechanisms
Large volcanic eruptions can put particles and gases high into the atmosphere. Reflective sulfate particles can cool the surface temporarily by reducing absorbed sunlight; volcanoes also release greenhouse gases. These effects differ in duration and magnitude. NASA describes the evidence at https://science.nasa.gov/climate-change/faq/what-do-volcanoes-have-to-do-with-climate-change/ .
A sufficiently large impact can loft dust and other material that reduces sunlight, disrupting temperature and photosynthesis. Smithsonian’s account connects impact evidence to such effects: https://ocean.si.edu/through-time/ocean-through-time . Ordinary small meteors do not cause this global response.
Ocean circulation redistributes energy. Sediment and ice-core records provide evidence of abrupt past climate changes associated with circulation changes; the mechanisms and regional timing require careful study. Read NOAA’s evidence overview: https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/products/paleoclimatology/paleo-perspectives/abrupt-climate-change . Natural release or uptake of greenhouse gases also changes atmospheric composition, affecting the movement of infrared energy.
02 · Build understanding
Human activities alter the energy balance
Burning fossil fuels adds carbon dioxide; deforestation can release stored carbon and reduce future uptake by vegetation. Greenhouse gases absorb and emit infrared radiation, changing Earth’s energy balance. Measurements, physical understanding, and models show that human activities are the main cause of recent global warming. NASA compares explanations and evidence at https://science.nasa.gov/climate-change/causes/ .
Urbanization can replace vegetation with surfaces that store heat and reduce cooling from evaporation and transpiration. Compare EPA’s explanation at https://www.epa.gov/heatislands . This local heat-island effect is distinct from the global greenhouse effect, though a city can experience both. A hot parking lot alone does not measure the planet’s temperature trend.
03 · Build understanding
Connect claims to evidence
Make a matrix with event or activity, measured evidence, mechanism, likely scale, and uncertainty. Include eruption, impact, ocean-current change, greenhouse-gas exchange, fossil-fuel use, deforestation, and urbanization. Identify whether the source uses instruments, rock or ice records, experiments, or models. Avoid claiming that all natural events cool, all changes are instant, or one cold day disproves a long-term trend.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Use the linked scientific sources to complete the seven-row evidence matrix. Compare an eruption’s short-term particle effect with persistent greenhouse-gas additions. Explain why a local urban temperature comparison and a global temperature trend answer different questions.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
Rows should connect each event to a supported mechanism and actual source evidence. Particles may temporarily reflect sunlight; added greenhouse gases alter infrared energy transfer. Ocean circulation moves heat; impacts can block sunlight; deforestation affects carbon and surface processes. Urban comparisons measure local land-cover effects, while global trends require broad observations over time.
- All specified natural and human influences addressed
- Evidence distinguished from proposed mechanism
- Local/global and short/long timescales distinguished
- No single-weather-event inference about global climate
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Evidence for climate change practice →