Learn · Grade 8 Science

Design and test a drip catcher

Use models and repeated measurements to improve a small engineering solution.

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Define a problem before choosing a solution

A classroom plant pot sometimes drips after watering. Design a small catch tray from teacher-provided waterproof reusable materials. In this model challenge, it must fit within a 15 cm by 15 cm footprint, hold a 30 mL water test for 60 seconds without leaking, and remain stable beneath a teacher-selected empty lightweight model pot. These are design criteria, not claims about every real plant pot.

Draw dimensions, wall height, joints, and the path water should take. Identify what the model omits: real soil, heavier pots, repeated outdoor use, and long-term material wear. Ask the teacher to approve materials and assembly; use no sharp edges, hot tools, or electrical parts. Work over a larger spill tray.

02 · Build understanding

Test and improve

Build a prototype and perform three trials with the same water amount, time, and model pot. Record any leaks, tipping, and whether each criterion is met. Use a graduated cylinder for the volume and a timing device for seconds. Dry and reset the design between trials.

Choose one revision, such as a folded corner or wider base within the footprint limit. Predict how it should help, then retest. A taller wall is useful only if leaking joints and stability also meet the criteria. Do not claim the best-looking design is the best-performing design without results.

03 · Build understanding

Defend a recommendation

Prepare a labeled before-and-after sketch, trial table, and recommendation. Explain one tradeoff: using more material might reduce leaking but increase cost or waste. If no prototype meets all criteria, report the failure and propose the next test rather than declaring success.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Submit your problem statement, labeled model, original and revised prototypes, three trials for each, and an evidence-supported recommendation. Evaluate the model’s limits and explain the next change if a criterion remains unmet.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Successful responses report actual trial outcomes and compare them with all three criteria. Recommendations identify how a tested revision affected leakage or stability, acknowledge material tradeoffs, and distinguish model success from proof of long-term real-world performance.

  • Criteria and constraints explicit
  • Labeled model guides construction
  • Comparable repeated trials before and after revision
  • Evidence supports recommendation or honest failure report
  • Model limits and tradeoff explained

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Design and test a drip catcher practice →