Learn · Grade 8 Mathematics

Compare a unit rate and a fixed fee

Represent related situations with tables, graphs, and equations.

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Two invented equipment plans

Plan A charges $7 per hour with no starting fee. Plan B charges $12 to begin plus $4 per hour. For hours 0,1,2,3, Plan A costs 0,7,14,21 and Plan B costs 12,16,20,24. Graph both on the same labeled axes. Plan A is y = 7x; Plan B is y = 4x + 12.

Both have constant changes for equal time steps, so both are linear functions. Only A has a constant y/x ratio for nonzero x and passes through (0,0). In B, 12 is the intercept, not the hourly rate. A nonzero intercept makes this linear relationship non-proportional.

02 · Build understanding

Read a model in several forms

If a table lists (2,19) and (5,40), the rate is (40 − 19)/(5 − 2) = 7. Substitute: 19 = 7(2) + b gives b = 5, so y = 7x + 5. On a graph, find the same slope with a rise/run triangle and the intercept where x = 0.

For direct variation y = kx, knowing y = 18 when x = 4 gives k = 4.5. At x = 10, y = 45. Direct variation does not allow an added starting amount. Decide whether a context permits continuous inputs or only whole numbers before drawing connecting lines.

03 · Build understanding

Worked example: two ways to pay at a skate park

A skate park has two ways to pay. A day pass costs $6 per visit with no other charge. A membership costs $20 to join plus $2 per visit. Compare them with tables, equations and a graph.

Step 1: Make a table for each plan so you can see the pattern. For visits x: 0, 2, 4, 6 the day pass costs y: 0, 12, 24, 36. For the same visits, the membership costs y: 20, 24, 28, 32.

Step 2: Test each table for a constant ratio y/x, skipping x = 0. Day pass: 12/2 = 6, 24/4 = 6 and 36/6 = 6. The ratio never changes, so the day pass is proportional. Membership: 24/2 = 12, 28/4 = 7 and 32/6 is about 5.33. The ratio keeps changing, so the membership is non-proportional.

Step 3: Write the equations. The day pass is y = 6x, in the form y = kx with k = 6. The membership is y = 2x + 20, in the form y = mx + b with m = 2 and b = 20. The 20 is the cost at 0 visits, which is the y-intercept.

Step 4: Read the graph. The day pass line starts at the origin, (0, 0). The membership line starts higher, at (0, 20), and climbs more slowly. The lines cross at (5, 30). Visits are whole numbers, so only the points at whole numbers of visits are real costs. The lines show the pattern.

Step 5: Check the crossing point in both equations. Day pass: 6(5) = 30. Membership: 2(5) + 20 = 30. At 5 visits the plans cost the same, $30. With fewer than 5 visits the day pass is cheaper, and with more than 5 visits the membership is cheaper.

(0, 0)(0, 20)(5, 30)
  • day pass
  • membership
The day pass line y = 6x starts at (0, 0), the membership line y = 2x + 20 starts at (0, 20), and they cross at (5, 30).

04 · Build understanding

Worked example: from a table to y = mx + b

A table shows x: 2, 4, 6, 8 and y: 14, 20, 26, 32. Write the equation of the line.

Step 1: Find the rate of change from any two rows. Using (2, 14) and (4, 20): (20 − 14)/(4 − 2) = 6/2 = 3. Confirm with two other rows, (6, 26) and (8, 32): (32 − 26)/(8 − 6) = 6/2 = 3. The rate is constant, so the relationship is linear with m = 3.

Step 2: Find the y-intercept. Substitute one row into y = 3x + b. With (2, 14): 14 = 3(2) + b, so 14 = 6 + b and b = 8.

Step 3: Write the equation: y = 3x + 8.

Step 4: Check with a row you did not use to find b. For x = 8: 3(8) + 8 = 32, which matches the table.

Step 5: Decide whether it is proportional. Since b = 8, the line misses the origin. The ratios agree with that: 14/2 = 7 but 20/4 = 5. This relationship is linear and non-proportional.

05 · Build understanding

Worked example: direct variation with a garden hose

The amount of water from a hose varies directly with the time it runs. After 6 minutes the hose has delivered 21 gallons. Find the amount after 14 minutes, and the time needed to deliver 70 gallons.

Step 1: Write the form. Direct variation means y = kx, where x is the minutes and y is the gallons. There is no starting amount.

Step 2: Find k from the pair you know. 21 = k(6), so k = 21 ÷ 6 = 3.5 gallons per minute.

Step 3: Use the equation y = 3.5x to find an amount. At x = 14, y = 3.5(14) = 49 gallons.

Step 4: Use the same equation to find a time. 70 = 3.5x, so x = 70 ÷ 3.5 = 20 minutes.

Step 5: Check that the ratio of gallons to minutes stays the same: 21/6 = 3.5, 49/14 = 3.5 and 70/20 = 3.5.

06 · Build understanding

Three mistakes to watch for

Calling every straight line proportional. The line y = 5x + 3 is straight, but it crosses the y-axis at (0, 3) and misses the origin. Its ratios change too: at x = 1, y/x = 8/1 = 8, and at x = 2, y/x = 13/2 = 6.5. A proportional relationship needs a straight line that passes through (0, 0).

Swapping the fee and the rate. A dance studio charges a $15 sign-up fee plus $9 per class. The fee is paid once, so it is b. The $9 repeats with every class, so it is m: y = 9x + 15. For 4 classes that is 9(4) + 15 = 51 dollars. The swapped equation y = 15x + 9 gives 69 dollars, which is $18 too much.

Dividing y by x to get the rate when there is a starting amount. In y = 3x + 8, the point (4, 20) gives 20/4 = 5, but the rate of change is 3. Dividing one y by its x gives the rate only in a proportional relationship. Otherwise, use the change in y over the change in x between two points.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Create tables and graphs for the two equipment plans through 6 hours and compare their slopes, intercepts, and ratios. Write a rule for a separate model through (2,13) and (6,29). Solve a direct-variation model with y = 24 at x = 8 for x = 11. Explain how each representation reveals proportionality.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

A has slope 7 and intercept 0; B has slope 4 and intercept 12. The separate model has slope 4 and intercept 5: y = 4x + 5. The direct-variation constant is 3 and y = 33 at x = 11. Origin and constant nonzero-input ratios identify proportionality.

  • Construct and interpret tables, graphs, and equations.
  • Distinguish rate from starting value.
  • Use a constant ratio only for direct variation.
  • Connect graphical and numerical evidence.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Compare a unit rate and a fixed fee practice →