01 · Learn the idea
Two purposes, two drafts
Use the fictional lending-desk records or a teacher-approved researched topic. Write an informational essay that explains how a system works and what its limits are. Separately write an argument recommending a specific action. The informational essay should not quietly present an untested recommendation as a proven fact.
For the desk topic, an explanatory thesis might connect a clear procedure with understandable responsibilities. Organize a process paragraph, an evidence-and-limits paragraph, and a conclusion that synthesizes the explanation. Label all classroom scenario data as fictional. For a researched topic, cite the actual sources.
02 · Build understanding
Develop an argument rather than a slogan
An argument might recommend a limited trial of return-time cards. State why the intended audience can act on the proposal. Develop reasons with evidence and explain how each supports the claim. Address a serious counterargument such as time required to record details; respond with a test or tradeoff rather than insulting opponents.
Use transitions that name relationships: “Because the log cannot isolate the cause…” or “In contrast, the new procedure…” Avoid adding “therefore” where evidence does not justify the conclusion. A conclusion should explain the recommendation’s limits and significance instead of merely repeating the opening word for word.
03 · Build understanding
Check development
Highlight claim or controlling idea, evidence, and reasoning in different ways. If a paragraph contains only a claim and a number, add the explanation that connects them. If a detail is interesting but irrelevant, remove or relocate it. Each draft needs multiple developed paragraphs and its own purpose.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Compose two distinct multi-paragraph pieces: an informational essay and an argument on the same approved topic. Include a purpose/audience note, appropriate source attribution, a developed counterargument in the argument, and a comparison of the structures you chose.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
The explanatory piece develops a controlling idea through organized information; the argument uses evidence and reasoning to support a contestable claim while responding fairly to an objection. Both preserve source limits and avoid presenting fictional records as real research.
- Two complete pieces with distinct purposes
- Focused introductions and coherent developed paragraphs
- Evidence explained and attributed
- Argument includes substantive counterargument and response
- Conclusions follow from the development
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Inform and argue in paragraphs practice →