01 · Learn the idea
Primary does not mean unbiased
A primary source was created by participants or observers in the context being studied: a letter, photograph, artifact, or official declaration may qualify. A secondary source interprets evidence afterward. A later interview can be primary evidence of a person’s recollection, but memory still needs checking. A museum holding a document helps establish provenance, not the truth of every statement within it.
Investigate why Texas secession leaders favored leaving the Union. Read a teacher-selected portion of the Texas secession declaration archived by the State Library. The document explicitly defends slavery and racial inequality. Its racist assertions are evidence of its authors’ ideology, not facts about human worth. The authors sought to justify secession and did not represent the views of all Texans, especially those denied political power.
02 · Build understanding
Corroborate and distinguish questions
Pair the declaration with a secondary account of secession or Reconstruction. Record author or institution, title, date, original purpose, audience, and archive. Ask what each source can establish. The declaration strongly supports a claim about leaders’ stated reasons; it cannot show that every resident agreed or that its accusations against opponents were accurate.
For a contemporary comparison, choose an official population table and an advocacy statement about growth. Verify the table’s geography, year, and whether figures are estimates or projections. Identify the advocacy source’s goal and trace a numerical claim to its original source. A current publication can still omit context; an old document can be highly relevant to a historical question.
03 · Build understanding
Sources and research record
Primary: Texas declaration of causes, https://www.tsl.texas.gov/ref/abouttx/secession/2feb1861.html . Secondary context: https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/reconstruction . Contemporary data: https://www.demographics.texas.gov/Projections/ . Locate a dated advocacy statement using an organization’s own publication and save its title and link. If online access is unavailable, use teacher-provided copies with the same provenance fields.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Build a four-source evaluation chart: the declaration, a secondary history, a contemporary official table, and an advocacy statement. Identify source type, purpose, context, evidence, limitations, and a corroboration step. Explain one supported historical conclusion and one conclusion the declaration cannot establish.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
The declaration is primary evidence of its authors’ proslavery justification and racist ideology, not a neutral survey of Texans. Secondary history can contextualize it but also requires source evaluation. Contemporary tables need definitions and dates; advocacy claims need verification beyond the organization’s preference.
- Actually locate and use sources with provenance.
- Separate bias from the usefulness of a source for a particular question.
- Identify missing perspectives and corroboration.
- Evaluate historical and contemporary sources.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
A source laboratory: evidence, purpose, and bias practice →