01 · Learn the idea
Hazards meet human decisions
The Galveston Hurricane of 1900 devastated a low coastal city. Later seawall construction and grade raising modified the environment to reduce risk. These projects required public decisions and money and affected how people lived and rebuilt. Protective structures reduce some risks; they do not eliminate every flood or storm danger. Transport routes affect evacuation and recovery, while reliable warnings and communication affect the time available to respond.
During the Dust Bowl, drought and wind combined with exposed soil to damage agriculture in the Texas Panhandle and surrounding plains. Land use mattered as well as weather. Crop losses harmed incomes and contributed to movement of people. Soil-conservation practices were responses to the interaction of human activity and physical conditions.
02 · Build understanding
Limited resources require tradeoffs
Irrigation moves water to crops and can support production in dry areas. Pumping groundwater faster than it is replenished can reduce future supplies. Water conservation is adaptation in behavior; canals, reservoirs, and wells physically modify environments. A project can provide a benefit and still carry costs for habitats, communities, or future users.
Wind and solar energy provide alternatives to burning fossil fuels for electricity. Their output varies with weather and time; transmission, storage, land use, and cost affect decisions. A community comparing energy sources should consider reliability, jobs, land, water, and pollution rather than assuming one source has no tradeoffs.
03 · Build understanding
Sources
Galveston seawall marker: https://atlas.thc.texas.gov/Details/5167007475 ; National Weather Service Dust Bowl: https://www.weather.gov/ama/dust_bowl_versus_today ; Texas Water Development Board groundwater: https://www.twdb.texas.gov/groundwater/ .
Apply and explain
Your turn
Make four cause-response-consequence chains: Galveston hurricane, Dust Bowl, limited irrigation water, and a proposed wind or solar project. Identify a physical factor, a human decision, an economic effect, a social effect, and a government decision in each. Recommend one response with a benefit, cost, and uncertainty.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
Chains should connect coastal exposure to protection/rebuilding, drought and soil exposure to agricultural loss/conservation, water scarcity to allocation/conservation choices, and variable renewable resources to siting and grid decisions. Recommendations may differ but must evaluate both benefits and costs.
- Address all four cases.
- Connect physical and human factors.
- Identify political, economic, and social consequences.
- Avoid promising that engineering eliminates all risk.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Environment and community decisions practice →