01 · Learn the idea
Source A: Route Check Report — original invented report
Controlling idea: Testing routes under different conditions reveals problems a sunny-day sketch may miss. Category 1, access: under the subcategory width, the west entrance had room for two people side by side; under steps, the north entrance had three steps. Category 2, weather: after rain, the gym path held standing water while the west path remained passable in this test. These observations describe one invented school site, not a claim about all entrances.
Comparison display, described for drawing: rows Gym, North, West; columns Standing water observed and Steps observed. Gym: yes, zero. North: no, three. West: no, zero. Draw the display and label it “One invented observation session.” Source acknowledgement: compiled from the fictional student route team’s observation sheet; no measurements of width or repeated weather sessions were supplied.
02 · Build understanding
Source B: Try a Supervised Route Trial — original argument
To the book-exchange planning committee: We should test the west entrance with a supervised arrival trial before selecting the main route. The route report shows no observed standing water or steps there. A labeled trial could reveal crowding that one quiet observation missed. This proposal asks for a test, not a promise that the west entrance is suitable for every visitor.
Some members favor the gym path because it is familiar. Familiarity matters, but the report records standing water there after rain. Another option is delaying the decision until several weather checks are complete; that would provide more evidence but leave less preparation time. A supervised trial now, followed by a final conditions check, balances those concerns.
03 · Build understanding
Read the structure as a choice
Source A groups observations into categories and subcategories so readers can compare features. Its acknowledgement explains where the information came from and a limitation. Source B uses a problem, recommendation, evidence, and alternatives to persuade a committee to take a specific next step.
The comparison display makes similarities and differences easier to scan, but a “no” in one session does not guarantee no future problem. A heading guides attention; it is not itself proof of the claim below it.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Outline Source A’s controlling idea, categories, subcategories, and supporting evidence. Explain the purpose of its display and acknowledgement. For Source B, identify the claim, audience, two evidence/reasoning moves, and an alternative considered. Compare how their structures serve their purposes.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A explains what a limited test reveals using access/weather organization; the display aids comparison and the note reveals provenance and limits. B asks the planning committee to conduct a supervised west-entrance trial, using reported observations and reasoning about missing crowd data while considering familiarity and delay.
- Separate reporting from advocating an action.
- Identify categories, subcategories, and source features.
- Explain alternatives and audience.
- Avoid treating one observation as a guarantee.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Read an informational report and an argument practice →