01 · Learn the idea
Use the same evidence fairly
Invented classroom evidence: a 15-minute route trial found a queue at the west door; volunteers then tested a side entrance with small groups and observed no blocked doorway during that trial. A committee has one practice session left. Possible choices include another side-entrance trial or redesigning the west-door arrival sequence.
Make a specific claim for this committee, such as “Use the remaining practice session to test the side entrance with a larger group.” Support it with the observed difference and explain why a larger trial would address uncertainty. Do not claim the small trial proves permanent suitability.
02 · Build understanding
Give an alternative its strongest reasonable form
A fair counterargument is that familiar west-door directions may reduce confusion, so redesigning that arrival sequence could be worthwhile. Respond with evidence and tradeoffs: the observed queue warrants attention, and another side trial may be a practical way to gather comparison evidence.
A weak response attacks people: “Only lazy planners prefer the west door.” That supplies no reason the route would work poorly. An argument gains credibility by acknowledging the strongest relevant concern rather than inventing a foolish opponent.
03 · Build understanding
Organize a complete argument
Draft an introduction with the decision and claim, body paragraphs linking evidence to reasons, a paragraph addressing an alternative, and a conclusion proposing the next step. Use transitions such as “However,” “For this reason,” and “A further test would…” only when they express a real relationship.
Review each factual sentence against the packet. Mark your predictions as predictions and identify what the proposed test would measure. A confident tone can coexist with honest limits.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Write a multi-paragraph argument to the fictional committee recommending one of the two options. Use the supplied observations, explain reasoning, address a reasonable alternative, and conclude with a measurable next step. Underline one sentence that acknowledges uncertainty.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
Either option can be defended with accurate use of the evidence and a fair tradeoff. The argument must not invent trial results, erase the queue observation, or claim permanent success. A measurable next step might record queue length and blocked-doorway incidents in a larger supervised trial.
- State a decision-specific claim.
- Connect evidence to reasons rather than merely list it.
- Address an alternative fairly.
- Use a conclusion and an explicit limitation.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Develop an argument with alternatives practice →