01 · Learn the idea
A source depends on the question
Research how a documented building in Samarkand has been used and represented. Locate a historical photograph or artifact record in a museum or archive and a scholarly or heritage overview such as UNESCO’s site description. A photograph can be primary evidence of the view it records; an overview is secondary interpretation of a wider history.
An eyewitness source is not automatically complete or accurate. A photograph has a frame, time, and purpose; it may omit nearby activity. A later historian may compare many records but still make choices. Record creator, title, date if provided, repository or publisher, and location or link. Do not invent missing details.
02 · Build understanding
Evaluate and corroborate
Ask whether the source is relevant to your question, whether its creator could know the claim, what purpose shaped it, and whether independent evidence agrees. A tourism promotion may highlight beauty while omitting maintenance problems. That viewpoint does not make every statement false, but it affects what questions you should ask.
Compare the photograph’s visible details with the overview. Mark observation, interpretation, and unanswered question separately. To check accuracy, look for independent confirmation rather than counting copied versions of the same claim as independent sources.
03 · Build understanding
Credit the work
Quote exact words with quotation marks and a citation. Paraphrase by restating the meaning in your own structure and wording, still citing the source. Include a bibliography using your teacher’s format. Copying an image also requires attention to its use conditions and attribution; you may instead describe it and link to the collection record.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Create two source cards, one for primary evidence and one for a secondary account. Evaluate a claim using both, then write a cited paraphrase and a bibliography entry for each.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A strong response identifies actual sources, explains what each can establish, notes limits and viewpoints, and uses original wording with accurate attribution. The conclusion should not claim more than the sources show.
- Locate and use relevant sources.
- Explain primary/secondary status for the question.
- Evaluate and corroborate evidence.
- Cite without plagiarism or invented details.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Source detective practice →