01 · Learn the idea
Different scientific tools
A hypothesis is a testable proposed explanation or prediction, such as “a taller barrier will reduce escapes under these release conditions.” A scientific theory explains a broad body of evidence. A scientific law describes a consistent relationship in nature. A theory does not turn into a law just by becoming older or better supported.
02 · Build understanding
A model and an argument
Illustrative tests: shallow box holds the car in 2 of 5 trials; deeper box holds it in 5 of 5. Draw both with labeled barrier height and incoming motion arrows. Recommend the deeper box for another round of testing using the recorded results, while acknowledging the small sample.
A partner says one successful shallow-box trial proves it is equally reliable. Respond: “That trial shows it can work, but the full set has three escapes. Let’s repeat both designs under matched conditions.” Individually label a model, then present a group explanation using a claim, evidence, and reasoning. Change the claim if new trials disagree.
03 · Build understanding
Scale changes relationships
If a square base changes from 10 cm per side to 20 cm, its area changes from 100 to 400 square centimeters: twice the side gives four times the area. A cube with every length doubled has eight times the volume. More material and a larger footprint may violate design limits, so a small model’s success does not automatically transfer to a larger system.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Prepare a labeled model and a short evidence-based recommendation for the catch box. Include a respectful reply to the competing claim and a scale limitation.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
The deeper box retained the car in 5/5 trials versus 2/5, supporting further testing of it. Acknowledge the successful shallow trial but compare all trials. Doubling base length quadruples area, so scaling may exceed material or space limits.
- Use all trial results.
- Explain model limits.
- Respond to evidence respectfully.
- Distinguish hypothesis, theory, and law.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Models and scientific arguments practice →