01 · Learn the idea
Subtraction asks you to remove
Model 5 − 3 with five positive counters and remove three positives. Two positives remain. The same removal idea works with negative counters: for −5 − (−3), begin with five negatives, remove three negatives, and leave two negatives. The result is −2.
02 · Build understanding
Add zero pairs when a counter is missing
To model 2 − 5, start with two positives. You need to remove five positives, but only two are available. Add three zero pairs. Now there are five positives and three negatives, still totaling 2. Remove the five positives. Three negatives remain, so 2 − 5 = −3.
To model 2 − (−5), start with two positives and add five zero pairs. There are now seven positives and five negatives, still totaling 2. Remove the five negatives. Seven positives remain, so 2 − (−5) = 7. Adding zero pairs prepares the model without changing its starting value.
03 · Build understanding
Connect removal to a rule
Removing positive counters has the same effect on value as adding negatives. Removing negative counters has the same effect as adding positives. Therefore a − b = a + (the opposite of b). For example, −4 − (−6) = −4 + 6 = 2, while −4 − 6 = −4 + (−6) = −10. Change subtraction to addition and take the opposite of the second number; keep the first number unchanged.
04 · Build understanding
Check with addition
If 2 − (−5) = 7, adding the removed amount back must recover the start: 7 + (−5) = 2. This inverse-operation check works even when subtraction increases the value. Subtraction does not always make a number smaller.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Build a counter model for −3 − (−5). Explain which zero pairs you add, which counters you remove, and what remains. Write an equivalent addition expression and check the result by addition. Then calculate −3 − 5 and explain why its answer differs.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
Start with three negatives. Add two zero pairs, giving five negatives and two positives, still totaling −3. Remove five negatives, leaving two positives. Thus −3 − (−5) = −3 + 5 = 2. Check: 2 + (−5) = −3. In −3 − 5, remove five positives after adding five zero pairs; eight negatives remain. Thus −3 + (−5) = −8. The subtracted numbers have opposite signs.
- Add two zero pairs for the first model
- Remove the correct signed counters
- Connect the model to −3 + 5 = 2
- Check by addition and distinguish the result −8
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Subtract integers by removing counters practice →