01 · Learn the idea
Analyze before choosing
A class needs at least 28 pencils and has a $12 budget. Store A sells packs of 6 for $2.10; Store B sells packs of 10 for $3.80. Ignore tax and travel costs, and assume packs cannot be split. The question is which single-store order meets the quantity requirement at lower cost. Record the givens, unknown pack counts, and constraints before calculating.
02 · Build understanding
Choose a plan and tools
Use counters grouped in sixes or tens to see why a partial pack cannot be bought. Use paper multiplication for exact costs and a calculator to check it. Estimate first: five packs near $2 should cost near $10, and three packs near $4 should cost near $12. These estimates can catch misplaced decimals but cannot settle a close price comparison alone.
03 · Build understanding
Carry out and justify
At A, four packs give 24, which is too few; five give 30. Cost=5×$2.10=$10.50. At B, two give 20; three give 30. Cost=3×$3.80=$11.40. Both orders meet the minimum and budget. A costs $0.90 less and leaves $1.50 of the budget, with two surplus pencils.
04 · Build understanding
Evaluate the process
Check exact arithmetic against estimates and verify both constraints. The claim “A is cheaper because each pack costs less” is incomplete: pack sizes differ. Our justification compares feasible orders with the required quantity. If travel or tax differed, the decision could change. Explain the selected model and its limits rather than claiming a universal best store.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Solve a new order: at least 34 pencils, budget $15; A has packs of 8 for $2.60 and B has packs of 12 for $4.20. Use the analyze-plan-solve-justify-evaluate cycle. Select a physical or drawing model, an exact calculation method, and an estimate. Present your conclusion with quantities, cost, surplus, and assumptions.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A needs five packs:40 pencils,$13,6 surplus. B needs three packs:36 pencils,$12.60,2 surplus. Both meet the budget; B costs $0.40 less. Estimates five×about$3≈$15 and three×about$4≈$12 support the scale, but exact calculation resolves the close comparison. Assume no tax or travel cost and whole packs.
- Explicit givens, plan, solution, justification, and evaluation
- Explain tool choices
- Correct feasible quantities and costs
- Compare both constraints and state assumptions
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Plan a class supply order practice →