01 · Learn the idea
Original committee argument
“School committee members, keep one reading room open at lunch. In our fictional student survey, 18 of 24 respondents requested a quiet indoor option. A teacher’s observation log also describes students reading in the hallway when rooms are closed. A room could offer space, stability, and quiet. Why leave readers searching for a seat?”
The claim is the proposed lunchtime room. The intended audience can authorize it. Survey counts supply numerical evidence; the observation log supplies a recorded example. Neither alone proves demand among every student. We need to know who answered, how questions were asked, and whether the log covers typical days.
02 · Build understanding
Persuasion and reasoning differ
Repetition, parallel wording, and rhetorical questions can emphasize a message without necessarily supplying evidence. “Space, stability, and quiet” groups ideas rhythmically. “Why leave readers searching?” invites agreement, but it does not prove that the proposal is affordable.
A false dilemma says “Either open this room or admit that the school hates books,” ignoring other options. Bandwagon reasoning says the plan must be correct because it is popular. Popularity can be relevant to demand, but it cannot by itself establish cost, fairness, or feasibility. Evaluate the actual link between reason and claim.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Identify the claim, audience, and two evidence types. Replace the false dilemma with a fair statement and explain one limitation of the survey.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
The claim requests a lunchtime reading room from the committee. The survey and observation log provide different evidence. A fair statement acknowledges alternatives; the small or nonrepresentative sample may limit conclusions.
- Identify evidence and its role.
- Distinguish emphasis from proof.
- Explain the reasoning error specifically.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Argument, evidence, and fallacies practice →