01 · Learn the idea
Read the fictional evidence cards
The town is considering a small reading park. These practice cards are invented, not actual surveys or engineering findings. Site R, beside the river, has an existing level path, is 200 m from the library, and would require removing six trees. Its card says seasonal high water could close the site. Site H, on a hill, is 400 m from the library, would require removing two trees, and needs a new accessible path. Costs and high-water frequency have not yet been estimated.
Turning either site into a park would modify the environment. A public reading space could benefit residents, while removing trees changes habitat and shade. New paths could improve access but require materials, work, and land changes. Name a specific possible consequence instead of assuming every modification is entirely beneficial or entirely harmful.
02 · Build understanding
Hear the priorities
Original fictional comment from a library volunteer: “I prefer the short walk to Site R, but I want to know how often high water would close it.” Original fictional comment from a gardener: “Site H keeps more existing trees. We still need a path that people with different mobility needs can use.”
The speakers emphasize different concerns, but neither says only one concern matters. A comparison chart can use rows for distance, trees removed, access, closure risk, and unknown costs. Distinguish a listed fact from a prediction and an unanswered question.
03 · Build understanding
Make a conditional recommendation
You may recommend a site if you explain your priority and what additional evidence could change your view. For example, choosing H to preserve more trees is conditional on a feasible accessible path. Choosing R for a shorter walk still requires considering tree removal and high-water closures. The cards do not prove a single best site for every resident.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Create a comparison chart using both cards. Explain the two speakers’ priorities without exaggerating their views. Write a recommendation naming a benefit, a possible negative consequence, and two missing facts you would request before a real decision.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
The chart should keep the supplied distances and tree counts accurate and mark costs and closure frequency as unknown. Either conditional recommendation can be supported. A strong response weighs access and environmental changes rather than treating the shorter distance or smaller tree count as a complete answer.
- Separate facts, possible consequences, and missing information.
- Represent both speakers fairly.
- Support a conditional claim and identify evidence that could change it.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Compare benefits and costs of changing a place practice →