Learn · Grade 5 Science

Choose a prototype using stated criteria

Evaluate more than one requirement and explain a tradeoff.

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Read the design goal first

A fictional school design challenge asks for a tray that keeps ten wooden blocks inside during a gentle, teacher-controlled table movement. Each tested empty tray must have a mass no greater than 120 g and must retain all ten blocks in each of three trials. These are the two announced requirements.

Invented prototype results: P—90 g, blocks retained 10, 9, 10; Q—110 g, blocks retained 10, 10, 10; R—140 g, blocks retained 10, 10, 10. Record the results in a table with separate columns for mass and each trial. Q is the only design that meets both requirements in these supplied tests.

02 · Build understanding

Use a model honestly

Sketch a possible next tray with labeled sides and a base. The table does not give the tested prototypes’ exact shapes, so do not pretend the sketch shows a known successful design. Label it proposed and state which feature you would test next.

A small classroom test allows repeated comparisons, but it does not reproduce every drop, weather condition, load, or shipping material. Meeting the classroom goal does not prove a tray will protect every real shipment. A design with taller sides might keep blocks in but might also add mass; the idea needs a new test.

03 · Build understanding

Discuss the evidence

Tell a partner which prototype you recommend and why. The listener first restates the recommendation accurately, then asks about a criterion or trial. Discuss the design and evidence rather than attacking the person. If a new result changes whether a requirement is met, revise the recommendation.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Make the results table, recommend a prototype using both requirements, and explain why the other two do not meet the whole goal. Draw one proposed change and name what you would measure in a new test. Record your partner’s relevant question and your response.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Q meets the 120-g limit at 110 g and retains all ten blocks in all three trials. P meets the mass limit but loses a block in trial 2; R keeps the blocks but exceeds the mass limit. A proposed side change needs measurements of both mass and block retention. The sketch is a hypothesis, not a picture proven by the supplied data.

  • Check every announced requirement.
  • Support the recommendation with the supplied numbers.
  • Label the proposed model and explain its limits and a peer question.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Choose a prototype using stated criteria practice →