Learn · Grade 5 Mathematics

Compare rectangles with the same area

Use unit-square drawings to distinguish the space covered from the boundary length.

Lesson 1 of 3About 30 minutesTEKS 5.4(H)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Covering and bordering ask different questions

A class makes rectangular paper displays from 24 one-square-centimeter tiles, with no gaps or overlaps. One arrangement has 2 rows of 12 tiles; another has 3 rows of 8; a third has 4 rows of 6. Each covers 24 square centimeters because the same 24 tiles are used. Draw the three arrangements and label their side lengths.

The border goes around the outside. A 2-by-12 rectangle has perimeter 2 + 12 + 2 + 12 = 28 cm. A 3-by-8 rectangle has perimeter 3 + 8 + 3 + 8 = 22 cm. A 4-by-6 rectangle has perimeter 4 + 6 + 4 + 6 = 20 cm. Equal areas do not force equal perimeters.

02 · Build understanding

Keep the comparison tied to the choices

If all three displays need a single border with no overlap, the 4-by-6 choice needs the least border among these three options. That conclusion compares the supplied choices; it does not say every rectangle with area 24 has that perimeter.

A second pair shows the other direction: 2-by-10 and 5-by-7 rectangles both have perimeter 24 cm, but their areas are 20 and 35 square centimeters. Equal perimeters do not force equal areas either. A list of correct calculations is useful only when you identify which measurement answers the question.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Draw tile arrays for the 2-by-12, 3-by-8, and 4-by-6 displays. Make a table of area and perimeter, and choose the least border among them. Then sketch the 2-by-10 and 5-by-7 rectangles and explain why equal border lengths do not guarantee equal covered areas.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

The first three arrays each have area 24 cm² and perimeters 28, 22, and 20 cm, so 4 by 6 uses the least border among the three. The second pair both have perimeter 24 cm, while their areas are 20 and 35 cm². Areas count unit squares; perimeters count length units around the edge.

  • Draw and label all five rectangles with consistent units.
  • Keep area and perimeter calculations in separate columns.
  • Support each comparison with the relevant measurement.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Compare rectangles with the same area practice →