Learn · Grade 5 English Language Arts and Reading

Revise a claim to match its evidence

Improve organization, precise wording, and sentence boundaries in a short explanation.

Lesson 3 of 3About 40 minutesTEKS 5.11(B)TEKS 5.11(C)TEKS 5.11(D)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Original draft to revise

“Our route check fixes every exhibit problem. Four of six fictional practice delays happened at narrow openings. I like green posters. Two delays involved loose labels. We should measure the door. We should measure the cart. The team of helpers are ready, they begins tomorrow.”

The first sentence promises more than the evidence supports. The green-poster sentence is unrelated to the route claim. The two measurement sentences can be combined. The last sentence has agreement errors and joins complete thoughts with only a comma.

02 · Build understanding

Revise meaning before editing

A clearer opening is “Our exhibit team should check the route before setup because it may reduce doorway delays.” Follow with the four-of-six detail. Then acknowledge that two delays involved labels and propose a separate label check. Combine the measurement steps as “Measure the cart and the doorway before moving the display.”

Arrange the paragraph as proposal, evidence, practical steps, limitation, and conclusion. Use words such as may when the evidence suggests a possibility rather than a guarantee. Keep fictional counts labeled; do not call them measurements from a real event.

03 · Build understanding

Edit a complete version

The phrase of helpers does not make team plural. When treating the team as a unit, write “The team of helpers is ready.” The pronoun they takes begin in “They begin tomorrow.” Separate those thoughts with a period or join them correctly, for example, “The team of helpers is ready, and they begin tomorrow.”

Apply and explain

Your turn

Revise the draft into a clear recommendation of about 100–150 words. Show one addition, deletion, combination, and rearrangement. Correct the final sentence’s agreement and boundary errors. Explain which change keeps the claim within the evidence.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

A sound revision recommends a route check, cites four of six fictional delays at narrow openings, combines measurement steps, and adds a separate label check for the remaining problem. It deletes the unrelated poster preference and avoids promising to fix every problem. The final sentences may read “The team of helpers is ready. They begin tomorrow.” Other correct sentence structures are acceptable.

  • Use a coherent claim-evidence-action structure.
  • Document four meaningful revision moves.
  • Correct agreement and sentence boundaries without exaggerating the evidence.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Revise a claim to match its evidence practice →