Learn · Grade 4 Social Studies

What makes a good leader

Identify leadership qualities of state and local leaders, past and present.

Lesson 12 of 12About 11 minutesTEKS 4.16(B)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Qualities worth naming

Common leadership qualities include honesty, courage, fairness, persistence, good judgement, and the willingness to listen to people who disagree.

These are not decorations. Each one shows up in decisions, which is where a leader can actually be judged.

02 · Build understanding

Judge by what was done

Anyone can claim to be honest or brave. The test is what a leader did when honesty or courage was expensive.

Sam Houston opposed secession and was removed from the governorship for refusing to swear loyalty to the Confederacy. That is evidence of courage, because he paid for the position he took.

claimed quality + costly action taken → evidence

03 · Build understanding

Local leaders too

The same qualities appear in a mayor, a council member or a school board trustee, usually without any public attention.

A local leader who listens carefully at a meeting and changes a decision in response is showing exactly the quality a famous figure would be praised for.

04 · Build understanding

Judging fairly

Leaders are people, and most made both good and poor decisions. An account that lists only one kind is not a judgement but an advertisement.

Judging fairly means looking at what they did, the choices actually available at the time, and the results, and saying so plainly either way.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Name four leadership qualities and explain why each has to be judged by actions. Explain what Sam Houston's refusal of the Confederate oath shows and why it counts as evidence. Then explain what a fair judgement of a leader requires.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Four leadership qualities are honesty, courage, fairness and the willingness to listen to people who disagree. Each has to be judged by actions because anyone can claim any of them, and the claim costs nothing. What shows a quality is what a leader did when acting on it was expensive. Sam Houston opposed secession and refused to swear loyalty to the Confederacy, and he was removed from the governorship for it. That counts as evidence of courage because he paid a real price for the position he took, which a mere statement would not have demonstrated. A fair judgement of a leader requires looking at what they actually did, at the choices available to them at the time, and at the results, and then saying so plainly either way. Leaders are people, and most made both good and poor decisions, so an account that lists only one kind is an advertisement rather than a judgement.

  • Four qualities named with the actions-over-claims argument.
  • The Houston example with the cost explained as evidence.
  • Fair judgement defined by actions, available options and results.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Government and citizenship practice →