Learn · Grade 4 Social Studies

Weighing the consequences

Compare the positive and negative consequences of human modification of the environment in Texas.

Lesson 7 of 9About 12 minutesTEKS 4.8(C)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Most changes cut both ways

Almost every modification brings gains and losses together. Judging one honestly means naming both.

A dam supplies water, controls floods and creates recreation, and it also floods land and homes upstream and changes the river below it for everything living there.

02 · Build understanding

Worked examples

Clearing timber gave farmland and lumber, and it also removed habitat and left soil exposed to erosion.

Draining wetlands created usable land, and it also removed the natural sponge that absorbed storm water, which can make flooding worse elsewhere.

03 · Build understanding

Who gains and who pays

The people who benefit from a change are often not the people who bear its costs. A city downstream may gain water supply while families upstream lose their land.

Asking who gains and who pays turns a vague argument into a specific one that can actually be discussed.

what is gained · what is lost · by whom · over how long

04 · Build understanding

Over what period

Costs and benefits arrive on different timescales. Ploughing prairie produced crops immediately and contributed to soil loss that appeared years later.

The Dust Bowl is the clearest Texas example of a long-delayed cost. A judgement made only on the first few years would have been badly wrong.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Give the positive and negative consequences of building a dam and of clearing timber. Explain why it matters to ask who gains and who bears the cost. Then explain why the timescale matters, using the Dust Bowl.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

A dam supplies water, controls floods, generates power and creates a lake for recreation. It also floods land and homes upstream and changes the river below it for the plants, animals and people that depend on it. Clearing timber produced farmland and lumber. It also removed habitat and left soil exposed to erosion. It matters to ask who gains and who bears the cost because the two are often different people. A city downstream may gain a water supply while families upstream lose their land, and naming both sides turns a vague argument into a specific one that can actually be discussed. The timescale matters because costs and benefits arrive at different times. Ploughing the prairie produced crops immediately, while the loss of the soil that the grass had held appeared years later. The Dust Bowl is the clearest Texas example: a judgement made only on the first few good years would have been badly wrong, because the largest cost had not yet arrived.

  • Both sides given for both modifications.
  • The distributional question explained with an example.
  • The Dust Bowl used to show delayed costs.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Texas geography practice →