01 · Learn the idea
What an explanation is
An explanation says why something happens, not only what happened. "The temperature rose from 8 to 20 degrees" is data; "the temperature rose because sunlight warmed the ground through the morning" is an explanation.
Every explanation has to be supported by the evidence you collected, or it is only a story that fits.
02 · Build understanding
Claim, evidence, reasoning
The claim answers the question. The evidence is the data that supports it. The reasoning says how the evidence supports the claim.
The reasoning is the part most often left out, and it is where the science is. Data placed next to a claim does not connect itself.
claim + evidence + reasoning = explanation
03 · Build understanding
Using models in an explanation
A model can carry part of an explanation. Showing the Moon model moving around the Earth model explains why the lit shape changes in a way words alone struggle to.
Say what the model represents and where it falls short, so the audience knows which parts of it to trust.
04 · Build understanding
Explanations change
When new evidence does not fit, the explanation has to change. Holding on to an explanation that the data contradicts is the one move science does not allow.
Revising is not failure. It is the mechanism by which scientific understanding improves.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Explain the difference between data and an explanation, using a temperature example. Name the three parts of an explanation and say which is most often left out. Explain how a model can carry part of an explanation and what must be said about it. Then explain what happens when new evidence does not fit.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
Data records what happened, while an explanation says why. "The temperature rose from 8 to 20 degrees" is data; "the temperature rose because sunlight warmed the ground through the morning" is an explanation. The three parts of an explanation are the claim, which answers the question; the evidence, which is the data supporting it; and the reasoning, which says how the evidence supports the claim. The reasoning is the part most often left out, and it is where the science is, because data placed next to a claim does not connect itself. A model can carry part of an explanation, as showing a Moon model moving around an Earth model explains why the lit shape changes in a way that words alone struggle to convey. When using a model you must say what it represents and where it falls short, so the audience knows which parts to trust. When new evidence does not fit, the explanation has to change. Holding on to an explanation that the data contradicts is the one move science does not allow, and revising is not a failure but the mechanism by which understanding improves.
- Data and explanation distinguished with the worked example.
- Three parts named, with reasoning identified as most often missing.
- A model's role and its limits stated, plus the revision principle.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Data and explanations practice →