Learn · Grade 4 Science

Asking questions and defining problems

Ask questions and define problems based on observations, text, phenomena, models or investigations.

Lesson 1 of 7About 11 minutesTEKS 4.1(A)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Questions start with noticing

A scientific question usually begins with something noticed: a plant leaning toward a window, ice melting faster on metal than on wood, a magnet pulling one coin and not another.

Write the observation down first. A vague memory of something odd rarely turns into a question worth testing.

02 · Build understanding

Testable questions

A testable question can be answered by collecting evidence. "Does a plant grow toward light?" is testable, because you can set up plants and observe.

"Which plant is prettiest?" is not testable, because no measurement settles it. Both questions are fine to ask; only one is a scientific question.

testable: evidence can answer it · untestable: no measurement decides

03 · Build understanding

Sharpening a question

A broad question such as "what makes plants grow?" cannot be investigated in one go. Narrow it to one thing you could change and one thing you could measure.

"Does the direction of the light change the direction a bean seedling leans?" names what changes and what is observed, so it can actually be carried out.

04 · Build understanding

Defining a problem

Engineering starts from a problem rather than a question: something needs to be made, fixed or improved.

A defined problem states what the solution must do and what limits it faces. "Build a container that keeps an ice cube frozen for thirty minutes using only paper, foil and tape" is defined, because you can tell whether a design succeeded.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Explain why an observation should be written down before a question is formed. Give one testable and one untestable question about plants and explain the difference. Sharpen the broad question "what makes plants grow?" into an investigable one. Then define a problem about keeping an ice cube frozen so that a solution can be judged.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

An observation should be written down first because a vague memory of something odd rarely turns into a question worth testing, while a recorded observation gives something specific to ask about. "Does a plant grow toward light?" is testable, because you can set up plants and observe what happens. "Which plant is prettiest?" is untestable, because no measurement can settle it. The difference is whether evidence could answer the question. The broad question "what makes plants grow?" can be sharpened to "does the direction of the light change the direction a bean seedling leans?", which names one thing that changes and one thing that is observed, so it can actually be carried out. A defined problem about the ice cube would be: build a container that keeps an ice cube frozen for at least thirty minutes at room temperature, using only paper, foil and tape. That states what the solution must do and what limits it faces, so you can tell whether a design succeeded.

  • The reason for recording an observation first.
  • One testable and one untestable question, with the evidence criterion.
  • A sharpened question naming variable and measurement, and a defined problem with a success test.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Scientific investigation practice →