Learn · Grade 4 Science

What a model can and cannot show

Identify advantages and limitations of models such as their size, scale, properties and materials.

Lesson 1 of 7About 12 minutesTEKS 4.2(A)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

What models make possible

Models let you study things too large, too small, too slow, too fast or too dangerous to examine directly.

A globe fits the whole Earth on a desk. A drawing of a circuit shows a path electricity takes that you could not see even with the wires in front of you.

02 · Build understanding

Size and scale

A model is almost never the size of the real thing, and that changes what it can show. A globe shows where continents are but not how thin the atmosphere is compared with the planet.

Scale can also be inconsistent. Many classroom models of the solar system make the planets far too large compared with the distances between them, because a correct model would not fit in the room.

right in some ways · wrong in others · know which is which

03 · Build understanding

Properties and materials

A model made of plastic behaves like plastic, not like rock or water. A clay model of a mountain will not erode the way a real mountain does.

That matters when the model is used to predict. A stream table of sand shows the shape of erosion well and says nothing about how long the real process takes.

04 · Build understanding

Judging a model by its use

No model is simply good or bad. Ask what it is being used for, then ask whether its limitations matter for that use.

A globe is excellent for showing the positions of oceans and poor for showing the height of mountains, so the same model can be right for one lesson and misleading in the next.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Give two advantages of using models. Explain how size and scale limit a globe and a classroom solar system model. Explain how materials limit a clay mountain or a sand stream table. Then explain why a model must be judged by the use it is put to.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Two advantages of models are that they let you study things too large, too small, too slow, too fast or too dangerous to examine directly, and that they make hidden relationships visible, as a circuit diagram shows the path electricity takes even though you could not see it with the wires in front of you. Size and scale limit a globe because fitting the whole Earth on a desk means features such as the thinness of the atmosphere compared with the planet cannot be shown correctly. A classroom solar system model usually makes the planets far too large relative to the distances between them, because a correctly scaled model would not fit in the room. Materials limit a model because a clay mountain behaves like clay rather than rock, so it will not erode as a real mountain does, and a sand stream table shows the shape erosion takes while saying nothing about how long the real process needs. A model must be judged by its use because no model is simply good or bad. A globe is excellent for showing where oceans are and poor for showing the height of mountains, so the same model can be right for one purpose and misleading for another.

  • Two advantages, including access to what cannot be observed directly.
  • Size and scale limits worked on both examples.
  • Material limits explained, and the fitness-for-purpose test.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Data and explanations practice →