01 · Learn the idea
Relevant means it answers the question
Information is relevant when it helps answer your research question. Everything else, however interesting, is not.
Judging relevance as you read is what keeps notes usable. A pile of interesting facts with no question behind it cannot be written up.
02 · Build understanding
Use a variety of sources
Use more than one kind: books, articles, websites, interviews, videos and reference works. Each has different strengths.
One source gives one view. Several let you see where they agree, which is the strongest sign that something is reliable.
several sources → agreement → confidence
03 · Build understanding
Record the source with the note
Write the source beside every note as you take it: title, author and page or web address.
Going back to find where a fact came from costs far more time than writing it down once. A note without its source often cannot be used at all.
04 · Build understanding
When sources disagree
Sources sometimes conflict. Do not simply pick the one you like.
Check which is more recent, which says where its information came from, and whether one is a better authority. If you cannot settle it, say so in your report, which is an honest and useful thing to report.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Explain what makes information relevant and why judging relevance while reading matters. Explain why several kinds of source are better than one. Then explain what to record with every note and what to do when two sources disagree.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
Information is relevant when it helps answer your research question. Anything else, however interesting, is not relevant to this project. Judging relevance while reading matters because a pile of interesting facts with no question behind it cannot be written up, so the work is wasted. Several kinds of source are better than one because each has different strengths, and one source gives only one view. When several independent sources agree, that agreement is the strongest practical sign that something is reliable. With every note, record the source: the title, the author, and the page number or web address. Doing that once costs far less than returning to find where a fact came from, and a note without its source often cannot be used at all. When two sources disagree, do not simply choose the one you prefer. Check which is more recent, which says where its information came from, and whether one is a better authority. If it still cannot be settled, say so in the report, which is honest and genuinely useful to a reader.
- Relevance defined by the research question, with the cost of ignoring it.
- Variety justified by strengths and by agreement.
- Source recording specified, and a real procedure for conflicting sources.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Inquiry and research practice →