Learn · Grade 4 English Language Arts and Reading

Reading an argument

Recognise characteristics and structures of argumentative text by identifying the claim, explaining the use of facts, and identifying the intended audience.

Lesson 5 of 6About 12 minutesTEKS 4.9(E)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Finding the claim

The claim is what the author wants you to accept or do. It is a position someone could disagree with.

If a sentence could not be argued against, it is not the claim. "Our town has a library" is a fact; "our town should fund the library on Sundays" is a claim.

02 · Build understanding

How facts are used

Facts in an argument are chosen for a job. The author gives a visitor number or a cost because it supports the claim.

Notice not only whether a fact is true but what it is being used to prove. A true fact can be used to support a conclusion it does not really establish.

claim ← facts selected to support it

03 · Build understanding

Identifying the audience

The intended audience is whom the author is writing for. It shows in vocabulary, in the examples chosen, and in what the author assumes the reader already knows.

A piece arguing for a later school start that talks about pupils' sleep and homework is aimed at parents and school leaders, not at other pupils, because it assumes the reader has the power to change the timetable.

04 · Build understanding

What is left out

An argument shows the strongest case for one side, so notice what is missing. Costs and drawbacks are often left out.

Asking what the other side would say is not being awkward. It is how you judge whether the argument is strong or merely one-sided.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Explain how to tell the claim of an argument from a statement of fact, with an example of each about a town library. Explain what to ask about a fact used in an argument. Then explain how to identify the intended audience, and why you should ask what has been left out.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

A claim is a position someone could disagree with, while a fact simply states what is the case. "Our town has a library" is a fact, because no one would argue about it. "Our town should fund the library on Sundays" is a claim, because a reader could disagree. About a fact used in an argument, ask not only whether it is true but what it is being used to prove, because a true fact can be offered in support of a conclusion it does not really establish. The intended audience shows in the vocabulary, the examples chosen and what the author assumes the reader already knows. An article about a later school start that discusses sleep and homework and urges a timetable change is aimed at parents and school leaders, because it assumes a reader with the power to change the timetable. You should ask what has been left out because an argument presents the strongest case for one side, and costs or drawbacks are often missing. Asking what the other side would say is how you judge whether the argument is strong or merely one-sided.

  • Claim and fact distinguished by arguability, with both examples.
  • The question to ask about a fact goes beyond its truth.
  • Audience inferred from specific signals, and the reason for noticing omissions.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Genres and structures practice →