01 · Learn the idea
Primary sources
A primary source comes from someone who was there at the time. Letters, diaries, photographs taken at the event, official records and interviews with people who took part are all primary sources.
They are close to the event, which is their strength. Their limit is that one person saw only part of what happened, and may have had strong feelings about it.
02 · Build understanding
Secondary sources
A secondary source is made later by someone who studied the event but was not there. Most history books, encyclopedia entries and documentaries are secondary sources.
Their strength is that they can gather many accounts and give the wider picture. Their limit is distance: everything comes to them through other sources.
03 · Build understanding
Comparing the two
On the same event the two often differ. A letter from a resident describing a flood gives vivid detail about one street. A later report gives the total rainfall and the number of homes affected.
Neither is simply more true. Using both gives you detail and scale at once, and where they disagree you have something worth investigating.
04 · Build understanding
Finding the central claim
The central claim is the main point the source is making. It is not the topic. The topic might be a new highway; the claim might be that the highway will harm the neighbourhood.
To find it, ask what the author wants you to believe once you have read it. Supporting details are the reasons offered; the claim is what they are offered for.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Name one primary and one secondary source you could use to learn about a flood in your town. Say what each would be good for and what each would miss. Then explain how you would find the central claim in a newspaper opinion piece about the flood.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A primary source would be an interview with a resident who lived through the flood, which gives detail about what one street experienced but misses the wider picture. A secondary source would be a later report by a historian or a government agency, which gives totals such as rainfall and homes affected but misses personal detail. To find the central claim in an opinion piece I would ask what the writer wants me to believe after reading, such as that the town should build better drainage, and separate that from the reasons they give for it.
- One source of each type, correctly classified.
- Strengths and limits identified for each.
- The central claim is distinguished from the topic and from supporting reasons.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Social studies skills practice →