Learn · Grade 3 Social Studies

Making a claim and supporting it

Develop a claim about a social studies topic and communicate it with evidence.

Lesson 6 of 8About 11 minutesTEKS 3.14(F)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

What a claim is

A claim is a statement you are asking others to accept. "Our town should build a new crossing near the school" is a claim.

A good claim is specific enough to argue about. "Safety is important" is too vague, because nobody would disagree and nothing follows from it.

02 · Build understanding

Evidence supports the claim

Evidence is the information that gives someone a reason to accept your claim. It might be a count, a record, a map, or a quotation from a reliable source.

Name your evidence specifically. "Many people say it is dangerous" is weaker than "the city recorded 14 near-misses at that crossing last year".

03 · Build understanding

Communicating it

A claim can be presented in writing, spoken aloud, or shown visually. A short written argument, a talk, a poster or a map with marked locations can each carry a claim and its evidence.

Choose the form that suits the audience and the evidence. A map is powerful when the argument is about place.

04 · Build understanding

Take the other side seriously

A strong argument shows that you have considered the objection. Naming the strongest point against you and answering it makes your claim more convincing, not less.

If you cannot answer the objection, the honest move is to adjust your claim rather than to leave the objection out.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Write a claim about something in your community that could be improved. Give two pieces of specific evidence, name one objection someone might raise, and answer it. Then say which form you would use to present it and why.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Claim: our school needs a marked crossing on Elm Street. Evidence: the city recorded 14 near-misses there last year, and a count showed 112 students cross that street each morning. Objection: a crossing would slow traffic. Answer: traffic would slow only at certain times, and a short delay is a reasonable cost compared with the risk to students. I would present this as a short talk to the council with a map showing the crossing point, because the argument is about a specific place and a map makes that immediate.

  • The claim is specific and arguable.
  • Two pieces of specific evidence are given.
  • An objection is named and answered, and the chosen form is justified.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Social studies skills practice →