Learn · Grade 3 English Language Arts and Reading

Finding and judging sources

Gather relevant information from a variety of sources, and tell primary from secondary sources.

Lesson 3 of 7About 12 minutesTEKS 3.13(C)TEKS 3.13(D)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Use several kinds of source

Relying on one source means relying on one person's account. Use several: books, encyclopedias, reliable websites, documentaries, and people who know the subject.

When several independent sources agree, you can be more confident. When they disagree, you have found something worth investigating.

02 · Build understanding

Relevant means it answers your question

Information is relevant if it helps answer your research question. Interesting facts that do not are a distraction, however good they are.

Keep your question written at the top of your notes. Before writing anything down, check that it belongs.

03 · Build understanding

Primary sources

A primary source comes from someone who was there or from the thing itself: a diary, a letter, a photograph taken at the time, an interview with a participant, or original data from an experiment.

They are close to the subject, which is their strength, and limited to one viewpoint, which is their weakness.

04 · Build understanding

Secondary sources

A secondary source is created later by someone who studied the subject: most books, encyclopedia entries and documentaries.

They gather many accounts and give the wider picture. For a science question a secondary source explaining echolocation is usually the better starting point, with primary data supporting it.

Apply and explain

Your turn

For your research question, name one primary source and one secondary source you could use. Explain what each is good for and what it might miss. Then explain how you would decide whether a piece of information is relevant.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Question: how do bats find insects in the dark? Secondary source: a university website page explaining echolocation, which gives the overall explanation but may simplify details. Primary source: a recording of bat calls with the frequencies measured, which gives the actual data but does not explain what it means on its own. To decide relevance I would keep my question written at the top of my notes and, before writing anything down, ask whether it helps answer how bats locate insects. A fact about bat lifespans is interesting but would not belong.

  • One primary and one secondary source, correctly classified.
  • Strength and limitation for each.
  • A concrete relevance test is described.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Inquiry and research practice →