Learn · Grade 3 English Language Arts and Reading

How arguments are made

Recognise argumentative text by identifying the claim, distinguishing fact from opinion, and identifying the intended audience.

Lesson 9 of 10About 11 minutesTEKS 3.9(E)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Find the claim

An argumentative text tries to persuade you of something. The claim is what it wants you to accept or do.

The claim is often in the first or last paragraph. Ask what the writer wants you to believe after reading, and state it as a full sentence.

02 · Build understanding

Facts and opinions inside an argument

A good argument uses facts as support. "The school recorded 14 near-misses last year" is a fact and can be checked.

"The crossing is the most dangerous place in town" is an opinion. Arguments mix both, sometimes in one sentence, so read carefully to see which parts could be checked.

03 · Build understanding

Who is it written for?

The intended audience is who the writer expects to read it. You can often tell from the vocabulary, the examples and what the writer assumes you already know.

A piece using simple words and school examples is probably written for students. One full of technical terms and addressed to "council members" is written for officials.

04 · Build understanding

Judging an argument

Once you have the claim, the facts and the audience, you can judge the argument. Is the evidence checkable? Does it actually support the claim?

A confident tone is not evidence. Ask what would have to be true for the claim to hold, and whether the text shows it.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Find or imagine a short argumentative text. State its claim as a full sentence, give one fact and one opinion from it, and identify the intended audience with the clue that tells you.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Text: a letter arguing for a crossing outside a school. Claim: the city should build a marked crossing on Elm Street. Fact: the city recorded 14 near-misses at that spot last year, which could be checked in city records. Opinion: it is the most frightening road in the neighbourhood, which is a judgement. Intended audience: city council members, shown by the opening "Dear Council Members" and by the references to the budget process, which students would not need.

  • The claim is stated as a full sentence.
  • One genuine fact and one genuine opinion are identified.
  • The audience is named with a specific clue from the text.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Stories and genres practice →