01 · Learn the idea
Make the process fair
Problem: shared markers are often difficult to find. Gather information by counting misplaced markers for two days. List options: labeled cups, a checkout chart, or a sorting tray. Discuss benefits and costs such as time, space, and ease of returning markers. Invite each student’s ideas, listen without interrupting, and explain disagreement respectfully.
Agree that each participating student has one vote and the option with the most votes wins; decide a tie procedure before voting. Count votes openly. A class vote chooses among suitable classroom options, not whether someone deserves rights or respectful treatment. Implement the selected system for a trial period.
After the trial, count misplaced markers using the same method. Compare with the earlier count and ask whether the solution worked. Keep, adjust, or replace the system using evidence and another fair discussion. Winning a vote does not prove a plan will work; evaluation checks that.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Run the full classroom process and keep a record of the problem, information, options, vote, trial, and evaluation.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
No option is automatically best. A complete process includes fair participation and actual evaluation after implementation.
- Consider options and tradeoffs.
- Follow agreed democratic rules.
- Evaluate with comparable evidence.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Solve a shared problem and evaluate the choice practice →