Learn · Grade 2 English Language Arts and Reading

Respond with evidence and compare narrators

Respond with evidence and compare narrators

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Two ways to tell an event

Third-person version: “Mara watched the red kite tremble like a leaf. She waited while the gardener lifted it from the twig.” First-person version: “I watched my red kite tremble like a leaf. I waited while the gardener lifted it from the twig.” The first uses Mara’s name and she; the second uses I and my as the character tells the event. Both are original classroom examples.

The author tells a story to entertain and explore a careful choice. “Red” describes a literal color. “Tremble like a leaf” is a comparison that helps a reader imagine movement; the kite did not become a leaf. Write: “Mara is cautious because she asks for help instead of pulling harder.” Cautious means careful about possible harm.

Retell The Kite on the Fence in order: trapped kite, choice to seek help, gardener’s action, move to a safer place. Paraphrase with new wording while keeping the meaning. Add a labeled illustration and a personal connection that does not replace the text evidence. Read a short informational source of your choice and make a second connection to compare responding across text types.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Write a brief evidence-based response using cautious, retell in order, draw a supported scene, and label the narrator in each supplied version.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

The first version is third person; the second is first person. A response must connect a claim to a supplied detail, not merely say the story was good.

  • Preserve meaning and order.
  • Use evidence and new vocabulary.
  • Explain viewpoint and descriptive language.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Respond with evidence and compare narrators practice →