Learn · Geometry

Check whether the first draw changes the second

Check whether the first draw changes the second

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

With replacement

A bag contains 3 blue and 2 gold counters. Draw a counter, replace it, mix, and draw again. Under equal-likelihood random draws, P(blue then blue)=(3/5)(3/5)=9/25. The first color does not change the composition for the second draw; the events are independent in this model.

02 · Build understanding

Without replacement

Without replacement, after a blue draw only 2 blue counters remain among 4. Thus P(blue then blue)=(3/5)(2/4)=3/10. The second probability depends on the first result. Independence means P(A and B)=P(A)P(B), equivalently P(B|A)=P(B) when P(A)>0.

Independent does not mean mutually exclusive. If a fair coin and a fair die are independent, “heads” and “die shows 6” can occur together, with probability 1/12. Mutually exclusive positive-probability events cannot be independent, because their intersection has probability zero while the product of their positive probabilities is positive.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Make two tree diagrams for the bag, with and without replacement. Calculate blue–blue and blue–gold probabilities in both cases. Explain whether two separate independent devices can produce outcomes that occur together.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

With replacement BB=9/25 and BG=6/25. Without replacement BB=3/10 and BG=(3/5)(2/4)=3/10. The coin/die example shows independent events can occur together. Independence is a modeling condition to justify, not a synonym for separate labels.

  • Conditional branch probabilities correct
  • Replacement assumption explicit
  • Independence distinguished from exclusivity

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Check whether the first draw changes the second practice →