01 · Learn the idea
Define the decision
A fictional garden needs at least 48 m² of planting area and no more than 30 m of boundary fencing; gates and paths are ignored for this model. Compare rectangles 6×8, 4×12, and 7×7. Calculate area and perimeter, then propose another feasible rectangle. Do not treat a scaled drawing as an exact measurement unless its scale is checked.
The first design has area 48 and perimeter 28, so it meets both constraints. The second has area 48 but perimeter 32, exceeding the budget. The third has area 49 and perimeter 28, also feasible. These constraints do not select a unique best design; choose and state an additional goal, such as least fencing among the proposals or fit within a measured site.
02 · Build understanding
Make the reasoning reviewable
Choose tools for different purposes: graph paper for layout, arithmetic for exact dimensions, and a spreadsheet or geometry app for comparing alternatives. Use an estimate to catch errors before exact computation. Present a scale diagram, labeled equations, and a table; explain what a changed constraint would do. If fencing were limited to 27 m, neither of the two feasible listed plans would work, so investigate another proposal instead of silently relaxing the limit.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Evaluate all three layouts, propose a fourth, and choose a design using a stated extra criterion. Draw a scale plan and present a two-minute argument. Have a partner question one assumption, then revise or defend your recommendation with calculations.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
For example, an approximately square 4√3-by-4√3 design has area 48 and perimeter 16√3≈27.71, below 30; a 6.5-by-7.5 rectangle has area 48.75 and perimeter 28. Different choices can be defensible with explicit criteria. The 4×12 design fails fencing. A valid submission compares alternatives and evaluates its process rather than claiming the constraints force one winner.
- Every constraint checked
- Fourth proposal calculated
- Tools justified
- Diagram, equations, and table agree
- Decision addresses an alternative
- Assumptions and revision explained
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Design and justify a garden layout practice →