01 · Learn the idea
Represent a system
Draw the tray as a watershed: arrows show water inputs, infiltration, runoff, and sediment transport. A model can help predict the direction of change while failing to represent roots, deep groundwater, organisms, and real storm variability. Scale and materials matter.
A hypothesis is a testable proposed explanation, such as roots and surface cover reduce sediment transport under specified conditions. A scientific theory is a broad, well-supported explanatory framework; a law describes a consistent relationship under stated conditions. More evidence does not turn a theory into a law: they serve different roles.
Use the runoff experiment to write a claim, cite numerical evidence, and connect it to a physical mechanism. A peer may propose different soil compaction as an alternative explanation. Respond by designing a control or repeat measurement, not by dismissing the peer. Present a labeled model and a two-minute explanation, then revise after questions.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Create the watershed model, identify three omissions, and present a qualified erosion-control proposal. Record one peer objection, the evidence it would require, and a revision. Distinguish your hypothesis from a general scientific theory or law.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A defensible proposal uses the lower runoff in the tested design while acknowledging uncontrolled compaction and small sample size. It specifies a replication or control that could weaken or strengthen the explanation.
- Use arrows and a defined boundary.
- Separate evidence from inference.
- Revise in response to a substantive objection.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
A model is a testable simplification practice →