Learn · English Language Arts and Reading, English IV

Refine a question and test source quality

Refine a question and test source quality

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Start broad, then make the inquiry answerable

Begin with an informal question about access to public reading spaces. Refine it into a formal question with population, place, and outcome. Example: “What evidence would a fictional town need to judge whether evening library hours improve access for shift workers?” Plan search terms, source types, note-taking, and a schedule.

Locate a primary data source, an institutional explanation, and a relevant argument. Evaluate author expertise, methods, date, relevance, incentives, corroboration, and omissions. Primary does not automatically mean accurate, and a source’s viewpoint does not make every claim false.

Test reasoning: a straw man misrepresents an opponent; a false dilemma offers only two choices when more exist; a faulty analogy relies on an irrelevant similarity; a non sequitur draws a conclusion that does not follow. Apply these tests to actual passages, not to people’s identities.

At each checkpoint, assess what the search can and cannot answer. If sources count visits rather than unique users, revise a question about new patrons or locate better data. Record the old question, new question, reason, and changed plan rather than hiding the revision.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Submit informal and formal questions, an initial and revised plan, an annotated source log, and a reasoning audit with examples of all four fallacies from teacher-approved or clearly labeled invented statements.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

The research process should show why revisions improve answerability and how source methods constrain claims. A credible source may still be irrelevant to the specific question.

  • Document question and plan changes.
  • Evaluate credibility and accuracy separately.
  • Identify reasoning errors precisely.

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Refine a question and test source quality practice →