01 · Learn the idea
Original informational report
“During a fictional four-week pilot, the library counted 120 evening visits in week one, 150 in week two, 130 in week three, and 160 in week four. Staff counted visits, not unique people. The pilot therefore documents use of evening hours but does not show how many new patrons were reached. A follow-up survey could ask which hours visitors would otherwise use.”
The report’s focus is what the data can establish. Its sequence moves from method and results to limits and a next step. Evaluate the clear distinction between visits and people, the lack of a comparison period, and whether its conclusion matches its evidence.
02 · Build understanding
Original argumentative proposal
“The library board should extend evening hours for one additional month while collecting better access data. The pilot recorded 560 visits, showing that the time slots were used. Some residents worry about staff costs; that concern is legitimate, so the trial should have a fixed budget and a review date. A longer trial will not prove every benefit, but it can test whether patrons unable to attend earlier hours gain access. Approve the limited trial and publish the results.”
This proposal addresses a board, gives an arguable recommendation, concedes a cost concern, and narrows its claim. Evaluate whether the evidence justifies the action, what cost information is missing, and whether the concession receives an adequate response.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Summarize both texts without changing the meaning or order of reasoning. Write a critique of each text’s structure and evidence; defend or challenge the proposed extension using only stated data and clearly labeled information needs.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
Total visits are 560. Neither text establishes 560 distinct patrons or proves net new access. A reasoned response can support a limited trial while requesting cost and unique-visitor evidence.
- Separate reporting from advocacy.
- Analyze evidence and counterargument.
- Preserve qualifications in the summary.
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Compare an informational report with a proposal practice →