01 · Learn the idea
Ask, search, and revise
Start with an informal question from the poetry or drama readings. Turn it into a researchable question, such as how two selected American poems represent belonging through different formal choices. Plan source types, search terms, milestones, and a method for recording passages. Locate at least four relevant sources including the complete literary texts and an institutional or scholarly contextual source.
At three checkpoints—initial search, note-taking, and outline—record what is working, what is missing, and a change. Narrow or otherwise refocus the major question after the initial search, explaining which evidence or practical limit prompted the revision. Save both versions rather than claiming the plan was always perfect.
02 · Build understanding
Audit reasoning as well as credentials
For each source record author or responsible institution, purpose, evidence, publication context, relevance, possible bias, and one claim checked against another source. Expertise alone does not make every inference sound; disagreement is not itself proof of dishonesty. Separate the source’s statement from your inference.
Test four original practice claims. “Scores rose after the poster appeared, so the poster caused the rise” assumes sequence proves cause. “When scores did not rise, an invisible influence must have canceled the poster” adds an unsupported rescue explanation. “The poster is effective because it works” is circular. “Do not ask about the poster data; the hallway paint is ugly” diverts attention with a red herring. Identify the hidden assumptions and what evidence would be needed. Do not attach these invented claims to real researchers.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Submit initial and revised questions/plans, three process critiques, four source evaluations, corroboration notes, and the reasoning audit.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A useful inquiry changes in response to evidence. Credibility checks include both provenance and the reasoning that connects observations with claims.
- Formal/informal questions
- Actual relevant search
- Revised question/plan
- Three process checkpoints
- Credibility/bias/accuracy
- Post hoc/ad hoc/circular/red herring/assumptions
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Refocus a question and audit the evidence practice →