Learn · English Language Arts and Reading, English III

Write a recommendation that earns its conclusion

Write a recommendation that earns its conclusion

Lesson 2 of 4About 90 minutesTEKS §110.38(c)(10)(C)

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Choose a defensible scope

Write a 600–900 word recommendation for a fictional committee about how to investigate the reading-room problem. Use the supplied fictional data and label them as such. Do not invent survey responses. You may argue for a trial, additional observation, or another feasible next step. State an arguable thesis and the audience’s decision.

Organize reasons in a deliberate order. For each piece of evidence, explain what it supports and what it cannot establish. Include a relevant value appeal, a serious counterargument, a concession where warranted, and a response that does not simply repeat the thesis.

02 · Build understanding

Test and revise

Have a partner restate the strongest objection before evaluating your response. Check for false choices, circular claims, and leaps from sequence to cause. Revise at least one overstatement. End with a specific action and a criterion for evaluating it.

A persuasive conclusion follows the evidence; it does not turn a pilot into proof of permanent success. Preserve uncertainty where the information is limited.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Submit the argument, evidence-to-reasoning map, peer objection, and revised passage with an explanation.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

Different recommendations can succeed if they fit the limited evidence, treat an objection fairly, and define a feasible evaluation.

  • Arguable thesis
  • Evidence/commentary
  • Audience and appeals
  • Counterargument/concession
  • Reasoned response
  • Specific qualified action

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Write a recommendation that earns its conclusion practice →