01 · Learn the idea
Movement across a selective boundary
Diffusion produces net movement down a concentration gradient through available pathways. Osmosis is net water movement across a selectively permeable membrane driven by differences in water’s chemical potential; in a simple equal-pressure model, water tends toward the side with more nonpenetrating solute. Molecules still move in both directions.
Cells also use energy-coupled active transport to maintain differences in concentrations. Homeostasis is regulated stability, not the absence of molecular movement. A potato tissue test investigates an effect of transport; it does not directly measure every pump or regulatory process. Background: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK26896/ .
02 · Build understanding
Conduct a controlled comparison
A teacher prepares similarly sized potato pieces and labeled water, 1% salt, and 3% salt solutions by mass. Use three pieces per condition. Record initial mass in grams and dimensions in millimeters; use equal solution amounts, the same temperature, and a 30-minute interval measured in seconds. Blot each piece consistently before final weighing. Record firmness without tasting.
Follow the teacher’s risk assessment and TEA safety guidance: the teacher handles cutting, use the required eye protection, clean spills, wash hands, and do not eat laboratory materials. Source: https://tea.texas.gov/academics/subject-areas/science/tea-texas-safety-standards.pdf . Document any deviations rather than adjusting results to match a prediction.
03 · Build understanding
Analyze the evidence and its limits
Percent mass change=(final−initial)/initial×100%. An invented 5.00 g piece ending at 5.30 g gains 6%; one ending at 4.75 g loses 5%. Compute each actual replicate before averaging. Use the solution conditions and observed pattern to propose a water-movement explanation.
Unequal dimensions, inconsistent blotting, tissue damage, and balance precision can affect results. Mass change alone does not prove that salt entered cells or that a particular membrane protein caused the change. Near-zero net change does not mean water molecules stopped moving.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Record a prediction, controlled procedure, nine tissue measurements, percent changes, averages, and observations. Explain the pattern using a membrane model and connect passive and active transport to homeostasis. Identify an error source and a follow-up comparison.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
Actual results must be reported as observed. A supported explanation relates net water movement to external solution conditions while considering tissue variability and procedure. The arithmetic checks are +6% and −5%; an approximately unchanged mass indicates near balance of net transfers, not molecular stillness.
- Safety and controlled variables documented
- Replicate measurements actually collected
- Percent changes use initial mass as denominator
- Transport explanation includes limits and homeostasis
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Investigate osmosis and homeostasis practice →