01 · Learn the idea
Build an evidence matrix
Common ancestry predicts inherited similarities arranged in branching patterns. Fossils document organisms and trait combinations through time; biogeography examines where organisms occur; anatomical homologies compare structures inherited from shared ancestors; molecular comparisons examine DNA or proteins; developmental homologies examine shared developmental structures and processes. Similar function alone can result from convergence. Background: https://evolution.berkeley.edu/lines-of-evidence/ .
Analyze this invented case, not an actual fossil discovery: mainland species M and island species I share a distinctive three-bone joint arrangement; distant species D has a similar swimming function but a different joint arrangement. At 100 aligned DNA positions, I differs from M at 2 and from D at 18. I and M also form the joint from matching embryonic tissue regions. Older local fossils preserve a simpler version of the joint, and the island is near the mainland.
Make a matrix for the five evidence types. These observations favor I and M sharing a more recent ancestor than either does with D. No single short DNA sequence or nearby location proves that relationship; sampling more genes, taxa, developmental stages, and fossils could test the inference. Shared developmental features do not mean embryos repeat a parade of adult ancestral species.
02 · Build understanding
Compare the tempo of change
For fictional successive rock layers, series A has mean shell lengths 10,11,12,13,14 mm; series B has 10,10,10,14,14 mm. A suggests gradual change in this measured feature; B shows stasis followed by an apparently abrupt change at the sampling resolution. Plot both against layer order, clearly marking that layer order is not equal elapsed time.
Stasis means little net change in a measured feature over an interval, not that all genetic change stops. Geologically rapid change can still span many generations. An abrupt appearance can reflect faster evolution, immigration, or an incomplete record. Punctuated equilibrium emphasizes extended stasis interrupted by relatively rapid change associated with speciation. Evaluate additional dating, sampling, and geographic evidence before assigning a cause. Source: https://www.digitalatlasofancientlife.org/learn/evolution/punctuated-equilibrium-and-stasis/ .
Apply and explain
Your turn
Create the five-column evidence matrix for I, M, and D and a proposed branching diagram. Graph both shell series. Defend the ancestry inference, distinguish the two fossil patterns, and propose observations that would separate rapid change from a sampling gap.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
The combined structural, molecular, developmental, geographic, and fossil observations support closer I–M ancestry while leaving uncertainty. Series A changes incrementally; B has sampled stasis and an abrupt shift. More closely spaced, dated, geographically distributed samples could test whether intermediate forms were missed.
- All five evidence types analyzed
- Homology distinguished from shared function alone
- Gradual change, stasis, and abrupt appearance distinguished
- Alternative explanations and further evidence identified
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Common ancestry and fossil patterns practice →